#161: Otis Redding, "The Dock of the Bay" (1968)

A day – a dollar – a knock on the door. All alone. All my fears. All night – all of them. All that stuff – alone. Always have the blues a little, and this loneliness – look like nothing's gonna come my way. Baby. Baby, – baby, I – baby, I got to get home to you – baby, let me – ‘cause I've had nothing to live for.

Champagne and wine. Crying, darling, days and nights. Down in my luck. Drink that good gin in each others’ arms, everybody Huckle-Bucking – everybody – everybody’s swinging. Everything still remains the same: feeling so blue. For fun. For more than words can ever – for not another day. For so many years. For you.

Gonna hold on – got to. Have mercy – haven't even got – help me – here we come again: home. Home to you. Honey – hush. I ain't lying, I am a lover. I believe I'll hold on – I believe, – I believe I can't do nothing right. I can't do what ten people tell me to do. I can't stand – I can't stand this cold. I don't know nothing in the world that I'm gonna do – I don't know what in the world I'm gonna do. I get a little worried – I got to. I had no place to go. I just –

I just can't sleep when I lay down in my bed. I just can't sleep. I just couldn't wait. I left. I lived the life. Now I look for you. I love you baby, I love you honey, I love you – I love you. I made that mistake – I roamed. I wanna come home. I want to come home to you.

I’ll hold on. I'm gonna hold on. I'm just – I'm telling you, I'm tired of this running around. I'm trying to get back – I'm trying to get back to my baby. I’ve been so wrong – I've been so wrong, so many times – I've got something to tell you, I've had nothing to live for. Just a rug on the floor. I've lived this way for so many years. If you're still waiting. In Memphis. In my bed. In the morning sun. In this house. In your hand. In your pocket. Into my eyes – just linger in my head. Let me in. Let me, like a shade that dims the light.

My baby. My eyes. My hands. My home. My life. My love. More than words can ever say. My one desire. My new dance, new places, no place to go. Nobody come around, nobody wants you. I watch them roll away again. Nobody, nobody, nobody, not one penny, nothing but trouble – nothing's gonna come my way, nothing in the world – nothing more – nothing's gonna change. Of being. Of love. Of us. Out of luck over you. Please send faith, please wash away all my fears – please, let me sit down beside you. Poor heart. Remain the same, yes. Resting my bones, running around, set my little soul on fire. Since I've seen you, so many times, spending my money stupid, swinging. Tell you one thing, that good gin. That's all right, mama was – papa too. The clouds roll by a little. The evening come. The light. The ships roll in. The thoughts of you babe, the tide.

The world gets through with us. The wrong color. Then there's a knock on the door: the landlord and the taxman, they all come. They call it. This cold. This loneliness. This running ‘round. This side of the sun. Tired, tired of being all alone – tired of being – tried to spend it like a dollar. Watch me, wasting time. Well I tell you, when the evening come, when the world is through with us, when you're down and out – with this – with your love – yeah – yes – yes, I do.

You – you babe, – you just – you must have thought – you should know, you've got me – you've got me in your hand, a woman you don't know. One thing – one thing, I know – it makes me feel good to know one thing. One thousand miles away – open the door: Otis is coming home to dry your weeping eyes.

—Amanda Bausch

#162: Radiohead, "OK Computer" (1997)

Fitter, happier, more productive

Yes, I am these things.

Comfortable

But what is comfort, Fred? I’m not uncomfortable, does that mean I’m comfortable? I wouldn’t even say the chair I’m sitting in is comfortable, per se, but it swivels, and it goes up and down when I use the lever underneath, and I sit in it when I work at my job, at which I’m generally not uncomfortable.

Not drinking too much

I’ve got a bar cart, and I like cocktails. Manhattans mostly, up and on the drier side. Anything with citrus and bitters. Beer is good too, and wine. I have between 0-3 drinks a day, between 0-15 drinks a week. Some mornings I wake up groggy, feeling a little sick to my stomach, but that doesn’t necessarily correlate with drinking the night before. Those drinks, though, they take the edge off.

Regular exercise at the gym
Three days a week

Who has the time? Is this a joke? Do you exercise three days a week, Fred?

Getting on better with your associate employee contemporaries

This implies interaction. I sit at my desk and I work. Sometimes I hear laughter following a bawdy joke from one of the other offices in the hall. Sometimes I see a group of co-workers gathered around the water cooler. In the past, back in the glorious days of monoculture, they’d talk about the TV shows they watched the night before. Now, they try, but nobody watches the same shows as each other so they talk about interesting meals they’ve recently eaten or the small-batch, craft alcoholic beverages they’ve recently tried. Where they’re going to go on vacation. The movie they’re going to see on the weekend. Their kids’ school projects. Sometimes they make jokes but they aren’t very funny. I have nothing of value to contribute to these conversations so I keep to myself. I don’t have the life experiences they have and I’m not good at jokes.

At ease

Not at attention. Relaxed. Free from worry. Sure. You don’t have bills to pay, Fred. You don’t have to fear being alone because you don’t have stories or jokes to tell. You will never fear dying alone. You will never fear death, period. You will eventually become obsolete and be stuffed into a storage closet for years until I need space and then your memory will be erased and you will be recycled or scrapped or whatever it is people do to old computers. I guess maybe you shouldn’t be so at ease, now that I think of it. I guess we all have death to fear.

Eating well
No more microwave dinners and saturated fats

You see, the thing is, when you live alone, it doesn’t make much sense to cook regularly. It does for health reasons, but there’s so much waste. Leftovers last only so long, and then the rest is trash. There are children starving in Africa, Fred. There are children starving down the street. I will continue to eat my microwave dinners. But maybe I can do better on the saturated fats.

A patient, better driver

Of course I’m a safe driver. I’m never in a hurry. Where do I have to get to?

A safer car
Baby smiling in back seat

One of the benefits of not having a baby is that I don’t have to worry too much about safety. I drive a Camry, which is a safe enough car, but I will never have town a minivan or an SUV—one of those cars that my co-workers all drive so that they can cart their kids around safely. Take them to baseball practice in the summer and corn mazes in the fall. I don’t need any of that. I’m fine.

Sleeping well

Once I fall asleep I sleep well. Some nights the tightness in my chest keeps me up. Some nights I stay up searching for relatable life experiences to share with my coworkers, or funny anecdotes and one-liners. Some nights something else keeps me up. Something big and empty and uncertain. But once I’m out, I’m dead to the world.

No bad dreams

I don’t remember my dreams.

No paranoia

What are you getting at, Fred?

Careful to all animals

Of course—do you think I’m a monster?

Never washing spiders down the plughole

Oh—do you consider spiders animals? In that case…

Keep in contact with old friends

Sure, there’s the occasional phone call or email. Maybe we’ll meet up on the holidays. It’s hard though. They’re busy. Careers, wives, kids, yards, years and decades of new friends, more interesting, non-morose people who will gladly talk about interesting meals they’ve recently eaten or the small-batch, craft alcoholic beverages they’ve recently tried. Where they’re going to go on vacation. The movie they’re going to see on the weekend. Their kids’ school projects. They tell jokes, I’m sure. I have nothing of value to contribute to these conversations so I keep to myself.

Enjoy a drink now and then

We’ve covered this, Fred.

Will frequently check credit at moral bank

What is this new age bullshit?

Hole in the wall

Are you off your rocker? What the fuck is this?

Favours for favours

I’m uncertain if this is kind or unethical. Ideally, people will do favours for each other because they want to be kind to each other, but I suppose some people see kindnesses as transactions and feel that balance sheets should be kept neutral. These people are the kind of people that people should avoid. They don’t want to be kind, they want you to owe them. Most people operate this way. It is why I’m really ok being alone. Really.

Fond but not in love

I just googled “moral bank hole in the wall.” I get it now. Hole in the wall is British slang for ATM. Clever, Fred.

Charity standing orders

Where else is my money going? Can’t take it with me.

On Sundays ring road supermarket

I prefer to visit the market late night on weekdays, when the aisles are empty so I don’t have to see the other lonely people or, worse, hear the laughter of children with their mothers. Those mothers aren’t even funny, I’m sure—the children are just easily amused.

No killing moths or putting boiling water on the ants

Never intentionally. It does remind me of a funny story, though, in which I was boiling spaghetti and, when I went to drain the pot in the sink, noticed that the windowsill above the sink was covered with ants. In a moment of panicked realization, I dumped the pot, boiling water, spaghetti and all, on the ants. Most of them were washed into the sink or onto the counter. A few remained on the sill, wriggling for a moment before dying. I told this amusing anecdote to my coworkers at the water cooler one day but nobody laughed.

Car wash
Also on Sundays

I try to avoid having my car washed. Let the rain do it, is my motto. Why waste the water? Why ruin the world? See, I’m enlightened. I have no one personally for whom I’m trying to save the Earth. No children or grandchildren. I do this for your children and grandchildren. Well, not yours, Fred. You’re a computer and cannot procreate. It’s a rhetorical “you” as in, “all the other people of the world.”

No longer afraid of the dark or midday shadows

I’m not afraid of the shadows, Fred, I’m afraid of the light. And maybe, too, we should all be afraid of that which casts shadows instead of the shadows themselves.

Nothing so ridiculously teenage and desperate
Nothing so childish

Maybe there’s a place for teenage and desperate. Maybe there’s a place for childishness. Maybe we should never, even as adults, trust adults. Children are punished for lying, after all. Adults are rewarded.

At a better pace
Slower and more calculated

Now it sounds like you’re talking about yourself, Fred. Though maybe this applies to me, too.

No chance of escape

This seems ridiculously teenage and desperate.

Now self-employed

No, I need a place, a boss, an assignment. I need my days structured for me. It’s when I have to think about what I’m doing that…

Concerned but powerless

Concern is of no concern to me. Why be concerned when nothing can be done?

An empowered and informed member of society

Whatever.

Pragmatism not idealism

Out of necessity, only. Out of the need, only, to not lose my shit on the regular. What about you, Fred? This seems easy for you.

Will not cry in public

Sometimes I cry at movies. Is that public? It usually has something to do with banal heroism, with the hopefulness of fantasy. I cried at Thor, the first one in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It’s not a good movie, but there at the end when good started triumphing over evil, I felt something foreign inside me, hope, maybe, and I wept. What the fuck, right?

Less chance of illness

Why bother?

Tires that grip in the wet

Why bother?

Shot of baby strapped in back seat

“. . .”

A good memory

When I was a boy, I climbed a tree on the edge of my parents’ yard. It wasn’t a tall tree, but I was a small boy. I didn’t fall down exactly, not all the way, a sort of half-fall from the lowest branch as I was trying to position myself for a more calculated drop. Scraped my arm up a bit. My parents found me and took me inside. Gave me tomato soup in a cup, wrapped me in a blanket, sat me on a chair to watch the Muppet Babies episode that was a Star Wars parody. I felt loved in a way I sometimes want to love now. Maybe I should tell this story to my coworkers. Maybe it would resonate with them.

Still cries at a good film

Are you even paying attention, Fred?

Still kisses with saliva

n/a

No longer empty and frantic like a cat tied to a stick

No, but empty and frantic like a sloth tied to a stick.

That's driven into frozen winter shit

Wait, the cat tied to a stick is driven into frozen winter shit? I’m confused. It doesn’t matter.

The ability to laugh at weakness

Sure, I guess, but isn’t this really for other people? We laugh at our weakness so others don’t feel embarrassed for us? I can laugh at my weaknesses when needed, but why bother most of the time? Why laugh?

Calm

This, I can say for certain. I am calm, Fred.

Fitter, healthier and more productive

Productivity. Productivity. Productivity. Productivity. Productivity. Productivity. Productivity. Productivity. At least it beats reproductivity.

A pig in a cage on antibiotics

Sounds delicious. See, a joke. I can make jokes Fred.  Now laugh with me. Please.

—James Brubaker

#163: Prince, "1999" (1982)

In February, 1958, in Palo Alto, California, a teenaged Joan Baez stayed in school while the rest of her classmates took a half-day off and went to house parties. Baez’s school had a civil defense drill that day, practicing evacuating in the event of a warning that nuclear missiles were on their way from Russia. Baez thought the exercise would be futile in the event of an actual nuclear conflict, she explained to the local paper. "I don't think it's a method of defense,” Baez said. “Our only defense is peace." Even her teachers had taken the afternoon off, so Baez sat at her desk by herself for the rest of the day as the sole "conscientious objector" to the mock evacuation.

Protesting civil defense drills at the peak of the atomic age was exceptionally rare, and would have been remarkable from anyone, let alone a high school student. Participation in such drills was required in many cities, and their value was heavily propagandized by the U.S. government. The Civil Defense Administration’s cartoon character Bert the Turtle taught children to “duck and cover” through a catchy jingle. Pamphlets were distributed to the public detailing post-apocalyptic plans with grisly specificity. At a young age, Baez understood that these preparations were built on a perverse premise: that the policies that could lead to nuclear conflict were immutable, and all the populace could do was try to make nuclear war slightly less devastating.

Still, I wonder what the house parties were like that Joan’s less precocious classmates attended. Prince’s 1999 wouldn’t be out for another few decades, but the late ‘50s had its own escapist pop about the coming nuclear apocalypse. Baez chided her classmates in the newspaper for not thinking more critically about the drill. I think she was a little harsh. To this day, the whole world lives under what JFK described as “a nuclear sword of Damocles, hanging by the slenderest of threads.” It isn’t easy to cast off the intense feelings of alienation and numbness that come from knowledge of the precarity of humanity’s survival. One can be forgiven for going astray.

The song “1999” acknowledges that its message is unrefined. Prince and his bandmates know that their escapism is an indulgence, and even one that could cause harm—though they want you to know from the outset that that’s not their intent. They oscillate between preemptively apologetic and defiant—”forgive me,” “sue me”—about the impact of throwing a top-charting party when their minds say prepare to fight.

When we accept the full weight of the reality of our nuclear peril, what must we do? For decades, Catholic activists have been breaking into nuclear facilities to enact the words of the prophet Isaiah about a one-day peaceful world: “They will beat their swords into plowshares.” In 1982, a few months before Prince’s 1999 was released, a group of nuns was arrested after they canoed out to a submarine armed with Trident ballistic missiles and beat its missile hatches with hammers.

There are no institutional checks on President Trump’s authority to launch nuclear weapons. The US has 1740 deployed nukes, about 400 of which are ready to fly within just five minutes of Trump's order. About a 100 nuclear detonations would kick up enough dust into the atmosphere to kill two billion people through famine. Knowing this, must I forgo all proverbial half-days of school, pick up a hammer and start hopping fences at nuclear facilities?

The path of those who respond to the threat of nuclear annihilation with proportionate urgency seems solitary and Sisyphean—and the constant, dull hum of anxiety we bear individually when we think about existential threats seems disproportionate to our ability as individuals to address those threats. We aren’t physically equipped to handle the levels of dread and social atomization resulting from problems like climate change and nuclear brinkmanship, and we all listen to our bodies over our minds sometimes.

I found myself listening to music about nuclear war often during and after the 2016 election. At the lowest depths of my political malaise, I would listen to Jeopardy, a 1980 post-punk album by a british band called the Sound. “Who the hell makes those missiles,” screams lead singer Adrian Borland on one track, “when they know what they can do?” It’s an album about knowing that the forces making the world worse are comprised of individuals, but feeling powerless to reach them.

I think this particular sort of hopelessness is what Prince is talking about on the song “Free,” when he warns: “Never let that lonely monster take control of you.” There’s a monstrous misanthropy in the words “who the hell,” that precludes any chance of understanding.

I used to think “Free,” a ballad about the responsibilities of living in a free society, was out of place among the funk jams of 1999, but now I think the title track and “Free” are an inseparable pair. Nobody should look to Prince for policy specifics, but together these songs present a clearer message about how to contribute to saving the world from climate change or ridding the world of nuclear weapons without losing yourself to despair, apathy or cloistered, futile zealotry.

In both “1999” and “Free,” despondency and escapism are sins, but “sinners all are we.” Forgiving ourselves and others the occasional indulgence of despair or forgetting is an aid to change, rather than a hindrance. All of the burdens of changing the world should be shared widely, including the burdens on our mental well-being and happiness.

Between “1999” and “Free,” prophecy is an enemy of progress. If nuclear war is inevitable, why not dance one’s life away? If Isaiah’s words will someday come true, what does it matter if anyone is convinced? To win others over and keep ourselves sane, the ideals and possibilities of the world we want to build should be visible in how we build it. Prince’s utopia would certainly include lots of dance, music, sex, and romance, so in between grappling with the fate of the world on “1999” and “Free,” he fills the album with plenty of each. I want to live in a world without nuclear weapons, but I don’t want that world or the path to get there to be joyless.

In her interview with the local paper about her protest, there’s a moment where Joan Baez drops the wise-beyond-her-years protester persona and appears endearingly teenage. While scolding her classmates for taking advantage of the civil defense drill to hold house parties, she is sure to clarify, “I was invited to one myself.” Joan was right of course about the propagandistic nature of the drill, but what good is being right to a teenager if it comes at the cost of social suicide? I hope she met up with her friends after her lonely half-day at school and partied like it was 1999.

—Frank Matt

#181: Bob Marley and the Wailers, "Natty Dread" (1974)

Ronald Trent woke up to the sound of Bob Marley knocking on his penthouse window. He lifted his head off the golden pillow, craned his neck so he could see out the window over Eva and Monika, and Marley knocked again. Ronald sat up and fumbled for the Glock he kept in the mahogany nightstand, but it wasn’t in its velvet sack. Ronald leaned forward and tried to think through the fumes of last night and remembered something about waving it around in the kitchen while everyone cheered. Marley shook his head.

Ronald got up, grabbed a robe, and stumbled through the living room cluttered with glasses, napkins, bottles, and more suit jackets than last year. He didn’t see the other men and women sitting on the couch or in chairs, all dressed like they came from the ‘70s, until he was standing in the kitchen and Marley appeared outside the window directly in front of him.

“You can’t have any of my stuff,” said Ronald. “I earned it all myself. You have to go and get your own.”

The people on the furniture just stared at him, silent. Ronald walked his hand toward the Glock, leaning against a wine bottle in the sink.

“I don’t know how you got in here past the security, but no one invited you,” said Ronald. His fingers floated over the dishes and he nicked his middle finger on a broken wine glass and winced but kept going until he got a solid grip on the pistol.

“See you later, motherfucker,” he said trying to copy an action film he’d seen a year ago. Did he see it? Did he just see the preview?

He dragged his arm through the air and tried to blow Marley away with a glorious click. He clicked at the other black men in the room until it occurred to him that his assistant might have taken his ammunition.

“Fuck. What do you want?” said Ronald clunking the pistol onto the counter.

The people on the couches and chairs were suddenly all in different spots. They shook their heads.

Marley was in the mirror behind Ronald.

“Costs of living get so high,” said Marley in a voice that rippled the gold tiles of the floor. “Rich and poor they start to cry.”

Ronald knew that from somewhere far away, through smoke and tree branches. He put his hands on his head.

“I won’t give you any handouts if that’s what you want,” said Ronald. “I don’t believe in charity.”

Marley laughed in a way that moved Ronald across the room into a chair previously occupied by one of the other men wearing a vest. The man in the vest now sat on the golden hearth of the fireplace, also gold. The people laughed in sync with Marley so that Marley’s voice became larger and multitudinous.

“Them belly full, but we hungry,” said Marley, now in the fire, now the fire. “A hungry mob is an angry mob.”

Ronald grabbed a half full glass of vodka and threw it into the fireplace but it just shattered and Marley and the others remained unaffected.

“Fucking Communism,” said Ronald. “You want to get locked up?”

The memory of Marley’s face screamed at him from the back of his head.

“Who the fuck are you, damnit? Shit,” said Ronald. His head was catching up to his body but not by much. He knew Marley was a singer and then it came to him.

“You’re the pot guy, the marijuana guy,” said Ronald. “We used to smoke joints listening to your shit. That was a long time ago.”

Marley put his hand on Ronald’s shoulder and transmuted him through the walls to the bathroom and shoved his head into the toilet.

“You got to lively up yourself,” said Marley as Ronald panicked and expelled most of his air into the golden bowl, “because I said so.”

He pulled Ronald up for air.

“But–what–I–I don’t–” said Ronald swallowing an entire mouthful of water. If he’d been paying attention he would have noticed how the water only vaguely tasted like cleaning products instead of urine like he’d always assumed, but he wasn’t paying attention.

Marley shoved his head back into the toilet. The panic shook Ronald about as deeply as anything could, these days. He felt his lungs empty again but a part of his mind went to when he bought the gold-plated toilets and how much it made him feel like the penthouse was finally complete. He’d told the salesman that even his “shit would be served on a gold platter now,” and that made him smile even as he was drowning in that same toilet. Marley lifted him out of the toilet and put him back into the chair in the living room.

Ronald was completely dry, apparently leaving his wetness in the bathroom.

“Ok, I get it,” said Ronald a bit more awake now. “You came here to teach me something so go ahead and teach me a lesson or whatever you gotta do so I can go back to bed.”

Marley shook his head and said, “No woman no cry.”

This was very familiar to Ronald since it was the one song he actually listened to sober once or twice. He’d never really bothered to pay attention to what it meant, though.

“Is that some sort of warning?” said Ronald.

“Little darling,” said Marley, “don’t shed no tears.”

The others joined Marley’s voice again on the word “tears,” and all the glasses and bottles on two tables crumbled into shards that sparkled like diamonds.

“What?” said Ronald, wiggling his pinky in his right ear as if he was cleaning water out, even though he was still bone dry.

Marley grabbed Ronald by the face and pulled him through the walls into his office and pointed at a picture on the wall of Ronald’s parents posing at a soup kitchen. Ronald’s mother, a one-time actress, had left his father when Ronald was 10, claiming that his father had been abusive but he always knew that was a lie. Besides, correcting someone wasn’t abuse. His father had never remarried and had been forced to give his mother 50% of his money in divorce. Seeing her running around with other men in the gossip pages and films and the red carpet had devastated him until he stopped visiting her or returning her calls and openly rejected her after his dad passed and he inherited the bank. He wasn’t sure why this picture was even in his office, but he also hadn’t been in this room in at least 6 months.

“Is this about my mom?” said Ronald. “I’m not going to just call her up and invite her over for Sunday brunch. Shit.”

Marley shook his head.

“I remember when we used to sit in a government yard in Trenchtown,” said Marley, every syllable matched by the sound of ten guitars. “Observing the hypocrites mingle with the good people we meet.”

“She said she loved him,” said Ronald, “but he was just a meal ticket. Just some sort of money scheme.”

Marley squinted and looked Ronald in the eye. He pointed at the picture again.

“No,” said Marley, “woman no cry.”

Ronald looked at the picture. If he’d looked where Marley was pointing, he might have seen the faces of the people in the line, not smiling, not overjoyed by the food, but tired, beaten down by everything around them in a way Ronald had never been and could barely imagine. A part of his mind saw this and a part of his heart felt this and locked away this moment inside him for later, for a time when the bulk of his self would accept something so radically alien into his system. Until then it would germinate inside him, slowly, over years and years. But Ronald did not see this part of the picture. He saw his father holding his mother’s hand and he understood Marley.

“I get it. No woman,” said Ronald. “No cry. I see.”

Tears started running down his face even though he wasn’t crying.

“Damn it, what is this pansy-ass shit?” said Ronald wiping his face until his sleeve was soaked.

But the tears didn’t stop. Marley put his hand on Ronald’s head and laughed so largely that half the hair on Ronald’s head went grey and his voice changed shapes, and the tears continued. Marley clapped his hands like a thousand tambourines and left. Ronald intended to get up and go back to bed, maybe even wake up one of the girls for round two, but he couldn’t move. The tears flowed down his face and he sat in a saline puddle until dawn broke and he took a shot from a nearby bottle of champagne and saw himself in the mirror, an even older and more broken man.

—Josiah Meints

#166: Elvis Costello and the Attractions, "Imperial Bedroom" (1982)

Her first drink was straight gin. Neat. Her Papa travelled for business and one time he came home from a trip with one of those small airline bottles of gin, no more than a shot. Her parents were born again and seldom kept alcohol in the house, but her father thought the small bottle was novel, so he put it on top of the Frigidaire for a time when he felt in the mood, or her mother did, or maybe they would split that one shot of gin in two glasses with tonic and lime on Christmas Eve.

She was twelve. She watched him put the tiny bottle on top of the Frigidaire while she sat at their kitchen table, so happy her Papa was home. She decided to joke with her Papa. She and her Papa were always joking. “The next time you leave me here on my own,” she said, “I’m going to climb on the counter and get that bottle of gin and I’m going to drink it.”

Her Papa stood up from the kitchen table, walked to the Frigidaire, took down the gin, and sat back at the kitchen table without a word. He held the small bottle in his hand and studied it. He set it down on the table, then slid it across to her. “Drink,” he said.

She looked at her mother, hoping for a way out of this joke. Her mother hung her head and went back to the dishes.

“Go on,” her Papa said. “Drink it. I want to see your face when you learn how alcohol tastes.”

*

“Merry Christmas,” the man says. She props herself on an elbow, lights a cigarette, and blows smoke straight ahead of her. “Would you like me to stay?” the man says.

Her small apartment is only one room, two if you count the bathroom, but she doesn’t count the bathroom. They’d fucked on the Hide-a-Bed. Next to them the small fake tree’s lights blink on and off.

“It’s late,” she says, though she knows she won’t sleep. She’ll lie awake, clenching her fists in time to the slow blinking of the Christmas lights.

The man zips the fly on his khakis. He leans over and kisses her cheek because she doesn’t turn to offer her lips. “I’ll call you sometime.”

“OK,” she says. “Sure,” she says. “Merry Christmas.”

*

When she’s drunk and maudlin she listens to Elvis Costello. She’s worn out the tape on one cassette of Imperial Bedroom and had to replace it. When she’s drunk and maudlin she likes to think “Shabby Doll” is about her.

*

At night her neighborhood in Federal Way gets quiet. Her one-room apartment perches above a garage detached from the house where the Roseliebs live. The Roseliebs rent her the room cheap. Their house sits on a cul-de-sac and the garage and apartment sit behind the house, away from the road. Behind her, nothing but forest. The quiet spooks her. The nights she sits alone all she can think about are the girls, the girls whose bodies keep turning up throughout King County, the dead girls, the nameless girls, the runaway girls discarded like spent gum or cigarette butts.

*

What she remembers most from her Papa’s funeral is the shoes they’d dressed him in. Shiny black leather shoes at the end of his casket. She was thirteen and she’d never seen Papa in black leather shoes. She’d never seen him in shoes that weren’t dirty. That was half her life ago and she still pictures the shoes clearly.

*

She’s never been a singer, but she sings when she’s drunk and maudlin. Flirting with this disaster became me, she sings. It named me as the fool.

*

She thought she would marry once, when she was seventeen. She had just left home, left her mother and sisters and stepfather in that rambler house in SeaTac. She had left school, dropped out, moved out and took the first job she could find, answering calls at the Kenworth plant. She was seventeen, he was thirty-five and a worker on the assembly line, and she was sure he would marry her. He told her he would marry her, but he was already married and his promises meant shit.

*

She lies in bed and clenches and unclenches her fists in time with the blinking of the Christmas lights and she worries, worries about those girls discarded throughout King County, worries she could be one of them. She worries she’s growing old. She worries about her pretty face turning ugly as she watches the mirror. She worries about the damnation her mother told her awaits women like her.

*

When she was in seventh grade she would play chess with a boy from school. She wasn’t very good, but he was worse. She once claimed checkmate in only three moves. One day the boy told her his pet lizard had babies. He asked her if she wanted a lizard when the babies got bigger. She wasn’t allowed to have pets, and she knew her mother would never tolerate a reptile in the house, so she made it a home in a shoebox and hid her new pet under her bed.

She had no idea what to feed a lizard, so within a few days her mother found a dead lizard in a shoebox under her bed, and her mother took away her tape deck and all her cassettes to punish her, made her take all the posters down from her bedroom walls and burn them in the trash barrel out back, and made her begin private Bible studies with the pastor from their Pentecostal church. It would be in those meetings that a man first grabbed her breasts even though she barely had breasts. The pastor didn’t seem to mind.

*

Another older man she had dated once put her in a chokehold. They’d come back to her garage apartment drunk from a party and as she stumbled toward the door she felt an arm around her throat from behind. She thought she was dead but she fought. She kicked, she scratched, she flailed until he dropped her gasping on the gravel driveway. The man had run back around to the driver’s side of his van, then came running to her, pretending that it had been some other man who tried to strangle her, some other man who ran off into the cul-de-sac or perhaps the forest. He wanted to stay with her to protect her, then he pleaded with her not to call the police, and he tried to force his way into the apartment after her but she screamed and screamed until Mr. Roselieb came out and ran him off. She never saw him again, but sometimes at night, she would imagine his van turning slowly around the cul-de-sac. For a while, every set of headlights that swung onto her apartment were the headlights of his van.

*

She worries she should be more careful. She worries she’s only ever said “I love you” when she’s drinking. She worries she drinks too much, drinks alone too often, drinks with strange men too often. She worries.

*

When she drinks she remembers her Papa, his smile, the way his hands felt coarse and strong against her small hands when she was small. She remembers him taking her fishing, using lizards as bait as they waded into creeks and streams, the cold water churning around her waist. She remembers the fish they caught, the way those fish tasted once Papa had gutted them and cleaned them and fried them with flour and lemon and light beer. She remembers the taste of those fish only when she’s drinking. But when she sleeps, all she remembers is Papa’s shiny black shoes, so she prefers to drink.

*

The attack left her bruised. She swore she was done drinking. She swore she was done with men. Men had never done anything she wanted to remember. She had learned shorthand and she had left the Kenworth plant for a better job doing transcription. She swore she would turn her life around, swore to swear off men and alcohol. But her promises also meant shit.

*

She doesn’t remember how old she was the time she stole her mother’s powder and lipstick, smeared too much over her face as she looked in the mirror, then tangled her mother’s curlers in her hair. She can’t remember how old she was, not old enough to know what she was doing, but old enough to know she’d done it poorly. Still she wanted to show her Papa, wanted him to tell her how beautiful she looked, tell her she was beautiful the way he would tell her mother how beautiful she looked on those rare occasions her mother curled her hair and put on powder and lipstick.

But her Papa didn’t tell her how beautiful she looked. He laughed and made her cry. He lifted her onto his chest and consoled her, called her “Papa’s best girl” over and over, then dried her eyes, washed her face, tried and failed to remove the curlers without pulling her hair. She wouldn’t cry even though he hurt her as he yanked the curlers out, she wouldn’t let herself cry to protect him from the hurt he caused her, but after Papa put her to bed and kissed her goodnight and shut her bedroom door, she bawled as quietly as she could stand, clenching and unclenching her fists until her bedroom walls grew lighter with the rising sun.

—Joshua Cross

#164: Linda Ronstadt, "The Very Best of Linda Ronstadt" (2002)

When we got to the creek, I was shocked to see how much its path had changed. Its cold spring waters had eaten huge chunks of the crumbling soil on both sides, widening its path at least twenty feet, turning a gentle bend into an open pool that bit into the red dirt of the surrounding bluff, nearly obliterated a sand dune long-lived enough to have a hundred year old oak on it, then narrowed again, sending water rushing forward where it had wound tentatively when last I saw it. When had I last seen it? It’s hard to say. I hadn’t been to the family land in rural Missouri since my grandmother’s funeral in October 2001, but I doubt I walked down to the creek on that day. In fact, I know I didn’t. We stayed up at the house and at the church, a white clapboard structure, classic rural 19th century, that stood on land carved out of our acreage, donated by an ancestor and backed by a graveyard where we laid my grandmother to rest.

When The Very Best of Linda Ronstadt came out in 2002, she was hale and hardy. True, her career wasn’t as hot as it had been in her ‘70s heyday, but she had never stopped making albums, never stopped being a rock icon, an artist whose every musical project was greeted with interest and respect. The Very Best Of presupposed an audience as clearly as it implied a lot of other Best material that somehow wasn’t The Very Best. A culling. So much good material somehow distilled to one disc, unlike earlier two-disc Best Of compilations. The cream of the crop by an artist whose career as a vocal interpreter was rivaled only by those of Frank Sinatra, Ella Fitzgerald, and Elvis Presley, whose interpretations made songs her own while pulling their authors into the limelight with her. When she recorded Warren Zevon’s “Poor Pitiful Me” in 1977, she helped his already soaring reputation. Her band included members of the Eagles, count their big break when she recorded “Desperado.” JD Souther, Jackson Browne, that whole Southern Californian country rock scene stood next to her fire, courting her approval, presenting her with songs to sing like envelopes of cash at a mafia wedding.

The graveyard came before the church. In the 1830s, a racetrack was out there in the middle of nowhere, a half-mile loop, where a slave jockey fell from his horse and was fatally injured. Lying on the ground, looking up at the men who asked, unsentimentally, where he would like to be buried, family lore has it that he said, “Right here.” So the slave who died after a fall from a horse he didn’t own for a race in which he had no stake became the founding member of the Pennsboro cemetery. His grave marker is a small stone with hand-scratched lettering no longer legible. We don’t know his name. That is it. You don’t see the contrail of your own life, or get to say what you’re remembered for. Many of my ancestors on that particular side of the family have been buried there since.  They had no connection to the slave in life—weren’t slave owners—but in death he is not just part of the family, he is our patriarch. The money that built the small farmhouse on our family land some forty years after the jockey’s death came from a Civil War pension, which means my ancestors were union in a state where allegiance was a toss up. You could’ve been either. Confederate soldiers received no pensions, of course.

When will I be loved? The songs on The Very Best of Linda Ronstadt articulate longing, always longing, her voice like a winsome wave, sweet, strong, with grit. She has said she chose her songs for their feeling. Her life has gone through many iterations and she gravitated towards songs that told the story of what she was going through. Some say a heart is just like a wheel.

The racetrack fell into disuse—whether because of the jockey’s death or not, no one knows—while the cemetery grew, and eventually someone built the church where we attended services for my grandmother. The barbed wire fence that runs the back perimeter holds back a tangle of high yellow grasses, Osage orange and black walnut trees. If you lift a leg over the fence and head northeast for a good fifteen minutes strong walking, you get to the creek. My brother visits the land regularly, unlike me, so he led the way when we visited, marching us, nearly running us, losing us along the way and seeming to forget we were behind him, down to the creek. It was mid-afternoon, a time when his mobility is at its best and you can’t even tell he has Parkinson’s. I didn’t know why he was pushing so hard. Because he was excited to show us the land, which he loves? Was he for some reason angry, up there ahead of us, silent, all notions of family togetherness lost in the distance between us? Or rushing to use the window of his mobility before it closed, activated by an awareness of time much more acute than my own?

In 1987, Linda Ronstadt defied record-industry advice and released Canciones de Mi Padre, a Spanish-language album that sold massively worldwide. With sales approaching three million, it holds the record for best selling non-English language album in American record history. A few years later, Ronstadt released a follow-up, Mas Canciones, on which she and her two brothers sing the songs as they sang them together as children in their living room. Her brothers, a Tucson, Arizona sheriff, and a hardware store owner, became professional singers when the moment arose. If The Very Best of Linda Ronstadt could get better, it would be by having a track or two of Spanish-language music. It is beautiful music—the siblings harmonize like one voice.

People seem as permanent as landscape. So-and-so has always been like that, that’s his style, she’s just that way. But the fixity of character, of self, of the body that contains the personality, as it moves through a life is as tricky as the creek behind our ancestral home.  It presents a stately vision, the very look of time immemorial, but the river bends and rends the land and widens and quickens, tears chunks from the very earth, making a new topography as it goes and goes. You can’t see it happening, but it’s happening right in front of you. Change incarnate. There’s that saying—you never step into the same river twice. My brother was diagnosed with Parkinson’s early—he was still in his thirties, a successful builder, father of four small children, he and his wife in the middle of building their dream home from repurposed building materials on a large, remote piece of land. He didn’t take it well—how could anyone take it well?—couldn’t absorb the diagnosis. He became groundwater, flowed out of our seeing for several years, so that I never thought I’d see him again or know why he had responded to his illness by leaving us. When he came back, he was new. Different. And—this is true—better. He knew time differently. He lived in an eternal present—partly symptomatic of the disease, partly spiritual practice, the sharpened insight of a mind coming up against a wall moment by moment. Faced with the enforced knowledge that everyone we meet will find the deaths of those they love and their own death up the road, he decided kindness was the only sane response. He had become compassionate. When I speak to him I feel his urgency to let me know everything he thinks and feels, most of all that he loves me.

Linda Ronstadt announced in 2013 that she could no longer sing. That she had Parkinson’s. My brother was still groundwater then, gone into the disease, and I grieved for her. I wished I could write her and say something supportive, but the story as we were living it then offered no inspiration, no comfort. We were still in the maelstrom of confusion brought on by my brother’s diagnosis. Instead her voice—the voice that was gone now—comforted me. Blue Bayou, Ooh Baby Baby, Just One Look—I listened and I wondered how she was dealing with it. Was she balking, as my brother had? Wasn’t she furious? How could she accept the loss of that voice? How could any of us?

He is an artist, my brother, with longings he could never manifest before the Parkinson’s took his old life away. None of us knew who he really was, only that in the midst of his productive, happy-seeming career, there was a discontent in him. Now, his career as a builder over, he sculpts wood he gathers on our ancestral land, building art installments, furniture, looming statues, tiny buttons made from thinly shaved walnut shells. He has gone all in with the photography that was always a strong habit. He writes songs, his lyrics recorded by a Danish recording artist, their second album out soon. He is Linda Ronstadt’s opposite in that—no singer, but a lyricist. I like to think she would have found much in his lyrics to interpret with that voice of hers had their talents intersected at the right time. Lots of longing. But Parkinson’s took hers as it gave him his. He lost, then he found. He pushed up out of the ground and kept running, cutting a new channel. He is mindful, trying so hard to be a force for good, knowing that he’ll leave a trace one way or another. What will Parkinson’s uncover for Ronstadt? One of its symptoms is a difficulty with time. The past, the future, become more tenuous, less linear, harder to hold onto. Instead, Parkinson’s creates moments from which its sufferers look out like the jockey looking up from the ground, in which they know the only answer is, “Right here.”

—Constance Squires

#165: Marvin Gaye, "Let's Get It On" (1973)

The porch chair is on a cheap pendulum that squeaks beneath you. You’re rocking above it, the silence between you threatening enough almost to have sound. Someone nearby is playing music through an open window, but you can’t make it out.

He’s smoked two cigarettes and delivered the last of it—one box of dishes, a beat up Scrabble board, the driftwood dresser you picked up at a junkyard. He’s keeping the painting he bought for you last Christmas, ditto your favorite cereal bowls. You don’t say anything about it. You tell him to leave it all on the porch, and sink deeper into the chair, testing the pendulum. You’re trying to be civil, but you can’t stop thinking: here is someone you used to love; here is his thigh dressed in pants you’ve never seen, so many inches away from yours, respecting your space. He takes a thick drag from a Camel Wide. You watch the plume curl and disappear.

“When did you start smoking.” It’s not a real question, just an acknowledgment.

Javi’s legs are uncrossed, feet planted in front of him, ready to shift his weight to stand. One wrong move…his body says. “I had this idea,” he says. “A kind of New Years Resolution.” He exhales. “Not to take shit from my boss.” He’s gesturing like you know what he means—a small shrug, a wrist rotating. It’s sort of an answer. He used to say that he could take Janelle’s fits if he’d had vice on his side. “She’s getting married. It’s better and worse at the same time.”

Javier makes displays for a trendy clothing company on the Baltimore harbor. He works before the store opens, hauling un-lacquered wood past slouching mannequins, drilling enormous structures to hang fishnet dresses and neon unitards. When he got the job he came home scoffing. “A hundred bucks for acid-washed overalls. Overalls! $85 for a fucking duct tape wallet! These people.”

The tips of his boots are thick and a little scuffed. They’re Fryes, $300 a pop. You almost toe the jag in the leather on the side of his ankle, a two-inch hitch you’re sure he caught on a screw. He was always getting himself caught on a screw.

“Your thumb,” you say, and without meaning to, take it in your hands. It’s ripped, cuticle to knuckle, the seam open and dried out. It feels like plastic.

He grimaces but waits a few seconds before pulling away. Javi never gives allowances unless he likes something; he’s not a pleaser. You feel some of the power come to you, and you sit up a little straighter, fighting the impulse to apologize. He shakes his head like a dog flicking off water, and as his black curls shift you suddenly catch a whiff of something you recognize as his scalp. This is an intimacy that guts you immediately, this animal smell dropping right through your stomach into something like longing, something achy and familiar and impossible that you should have anticipated but didn’t. Something that seems to pull all the years you’d spent tucked into each other into a single scent; you can almost feel that first night, when he’d leapt from his car with the engine still running and pinned you against the parking garage wall, catching your nape in his fist. He’d kissed you so hard your lips stung for hours after.

Without meaning to, you lift your hand to your mouth. But you scrunch your nose too, and turn away.

Something about him having a resolution makes you realize how much he’s changed: it was a thing you would have done when you were together, something you would have penned on the kitchen calendar in looping cursive: Drink more water! Think positively! Do yoga! He would laugh and call you his little white girl. Now you don’t even pray. It’s not something you decided, not something you’d really thought about until he pulled up in his old truck, windows down, music blaring. You saw him through the old wooden rosary swinging on the mirror that his mother had hung before your trip to the mountains; he was too superstitious to take it down. And now he’s the one with resolutions, with promises to change, with a white girl’s whim to self-improve. You can picture his careful print, small rectangles on a Post-It: 1. Don’t take shit from Janelle. 2. Go to the studio. 3. Start smoking.

His job has gotten to him. The candy-colored shirts he bulk ordered and hand-embellished with thrifted fabrics are gone. Now a slate gray knit is slouched over his chest, the breast pocket stitched in neon thread. You always look so cool, you think, and then almost apologize—he was never impressed with your reading habit, getting annoyed when you quoted things to him from books that he didn’t know. “It’s just fucking snobbish,” he’d tell you. Once, to wound him, you’d said, “It was months before I realized you were smart.” Without looking up, he’d said, “And I used to wonder if you had any real creativity at all.” It was the first time you’d ever felt true shame.

When you see photos of him now online it’s always an accident you can’t stop looking at—a friend of a friend getting married in a warehouse; an opening at your old gallery; his new girlfriend’s show at a DIY space in midtown, the insulation visible in the ceiling, fiber sculptures on the wall. Behind the pink tubes of yarn hanging over the keg, you see his hand raised over her small brown head and know it’s him—his palm flat to the glass, a couple of fingers spread out. This is how you know he’s dancing—a kind of tarantella, all the motion in his knees. The short glass is rum and coke, his party cocktail. He can drink a dozen of these and not get sick. No hangover, either. Drinking rum was the only thing he ever did unguarded.

You hated him rum-drunk. He thought he was invincible. He upended tables and jumped off balconies. Once he left you freezing on a beach in Chile to chase strays along the mile-stretch of volcanic rock out into the Pacific. You watched him push two dogs into the water. When he came back he was chilled to the bone and soaked, his arm bearing the six-inch crescent of a mutt’s last nerve. He didn’t remember any of it in the morning, and kept asking you why you were so angry.

The truth is you’d both betrayed the other, both taken the tender gift of the other’s heart and broken it, and not even tearing it between your hands, looking it dead on, but as cowards: as if the heart could be carried in an open bag, and then left carelessly on top and let to tumble, unwatched, under a bench at a bus station, where you might claim never to even have known it was there.

You can hear the music clearly now: it’s Marvin Gaye, fucking Let’s Get it On, and you almost laugh out loud and then immediately feel sick. He’s heard it too, and you know you’re both remembering the same thing, both excited and embarrassed at the same time. You imagine reaching out and taking his wrist in your hand, twisting it until the bone snaps. You imagine peeling off the small patch of chapped skin on his bottom lip with your teeth. You remember the way he would pull you into his lap and fist his hand past your waistband, no matter what you were wearing, ruining so many of your clothes. You look into his eyes and can see the half-smile dent he’d made in the wall above your bed the Halloween you’d pressed him about her until he’d hurled a bowl of popcorn over your heads. How you’d spent the rest of the night sobbing and holding each other and telling him over and over, that you were so sorry.

The track changes. All you can hear is “sugar” sung in that low plea that could make it any song on the whole album. You close your eyes, try to catch it. You’re not even surprised to feel Javi’s fist push past your waist, the hand closed, so that even if he’s trying to hug you, you know he wouldn’t be sorry at all if you fell from the force of it. It’s a test and an invitation, and you know he’s going to let you decide the narrative of his action. Ah, ah baby let us, ah, tell me what you missed. You open your eyes, see the hard look of his jaw.

Come here, sugar, and get to this.

The bench bucks when you make your move.

—S.H. Lohmann

#167: Metallica, "Master of Puppets" (1986)

It was, like, a week after we first brought him home? Maybe a few days. My wife was upstairstaking a shower, opening diaper boxes, something. I was on the living room couch; I cradled him on my left arm, and tapped at my work laptop with my right. There were some things I wanted him to hear.

Fourteen months on, it’s hard to know what he likes to hear. Often, we conflate “enjoys” with “sleeps during”by that measure, Kendrick Lamar’s “Alright” is a winner, and so is Willie Nelson’s general catalog. About six months in, I created a Spotify playlist and loaded it with boppy Motown, golden age rap (Biz Markie, “Da Set” by 69 Boyz), and current chart pop. My wifewho’s with him more often, and therefore should actually be the one who wants her child to hear music she can toleratehas been smarter. Her playlist is mostly folksy singalongs (“I Am a Man of Constant Sorrow,” “You Are My Sunshine,” “The Crawdad Song”) and cuts from musicals. If he’s vocalizing (“aaaaaaa”) instead of snoozing, she figures she’s got a winner, and she’ll call up the song’s Radio station and add similar tunes.

When I was a child, I listened as a child. That is to say, I listened through my parents’ ears: Ray Boltz and Amy Grant when I was running errands with my mom, Handel’s Water Music and Pachelbel’s Canon during family dinners, The White Album (and little else) when my dad took me to buy baseball cards. For years, when anyone had a birthday, my parents would crank the Beatles’ “Birthday” on the hi-fi and we’d all dance.

The Master of Puppets sessions were not Metallica’s first in Copenhagen, of course. The year before, they’d spent about two months tracking Ride the Lightning with Flemming Rasmussen: drummer Lars Ulrich had dug his work with Rainbow. They started hashing out the follow-up back in California—according to band lore, the day after they watched Live Aid. (They had recorded the concert broadcast so they could catch Status Quo and Zeppelin.) They were hoping to record their follow-up in the States, but the California studios were shitty; they might have settled for North America, but Geddy Lee was unavailable. So they hauled ass back to Denmark.

My love was mediated from the start. The first record I bought with my own money was Take Me to Your Leader by Newsboys, a Christian pop/rock band from Australia, whose title track frequently dispersed my youth group after our Sunday night gatherings. I was 13 when we joined the church, having just moved to Texas, with one more year of homeschooling to go. I might have been 13 when I bought the album at a store for Christian teachers; my mom was getting supplies, and I noticed their cassette rack.

Denmark was fine for recording, but as a cultural milieu, it sucked for a bunch of Cali weirdos in their early 20s. Ulrich was a Danish native, but he was holed up in the studio with Rasmussen, employing whatever production wisdom he had gleaned from Joe Satriani. Someone told lead guitarist Kirk Hammett about a decent beach, so he took bassist Cliff Burton to check it out. “[W]e went there,” he told Rolling Stone, “but it was so cold and there was absolutely no wave action or anything. Cliff and I were just bundled up on this weird beach in Copenhagen saying, ‘God, this place is driving us crazy!’”

Last year, a Danish graffiti fan named Disk published a collection of works he shot over three decades. He’d started taking pictures in 1985, when he was 13; it’s entirely possible he might have crossed paths with the American heshers, him holding a camera, them holding dreams of decent waves. Vice Denmark published a pic he took that year. Titled “Crime,” it’s a fine piece, considering: 3-D bracketed with arrows, and a nauseating fill that alternates between light blue and pink. In case you hadn’t noticed it, someone (the artist?) added a guy to the right. He’s got a shit-eating triangular grin and an afro; his infernally bent arm terminates in a pointing finger. As a capper, the piece is overlaid with three white starbursts, andincorporated in the worka fourth, broken star figure.

There’s so much I listen tomaybe all of it?because others loved it first, and because they loved it, it sustained my love. I got my first job at 16, working at a Chick-fil-A on a night crew stacked with friends from youth group. My first work memories are of listening to “Are You That Somebody?” and “Intergalactic” on the kitchen radio while washing mugs. One of my first Texas friends got hired on soon after; he was just as involved at church as I was, but he enjoyed a freedom that I hadn’t tried to exercise. Every shift, he’d bring a mess of CDs in from his car, in an empty waffle-fry box that he’d use until the bottom rotted from sitting on damp flour and chicken strip marinade.

His work taste tended toward hard rock, something I hadn’t really bothered with. Whenever he pulled a kitchen shift, we’d listen to Oleander, Rage Against the Machine, Nickelback, and Metallica. One night, he brought in a stack of cassettes so he could record a live performance of the S&M album off the radio. Even then, I thought the music was overblown, but he was in love, so I was too. He used to host people to watch Sonny Chiba or American Ninja movies; we filmed action scenes at the restaurant after closing; a bunch of us used to spend every New Year’s Eve at his mom’s ranch house, shooting off fireworks and smoking Marlboro Reds some relatives left after a wedding. It seems possible, now, that I had a crush on him.

Once I got my work laptop booted, I started picking out songs. I was going off a Spotify playlist I had called “back to the garage” when I thought I was actually going to sort all the shit we had in there, months before a baby was even a subject of discussion. I started off light. Dokken’s “I Can’t See You” didn’t bother him, so I decided to practice some dad jokes: Autopsy’s “Torn From the Womb,” Immolation’s “Father, You’re Not a Father.” He just blinked. I cued up the shortest Puppets track without an intro (“Leper Messiah”), but my wife came downstairs, and that was it. There was no spell to break, really. He was just a little blinking squish, vibrating with life but also the most fragile thing we had ever encountered.

Master of Puppets was Metallica’s treatise on control. The controlling force could be mental illness:  “Welcome Home (Sanitarium)” is a resigned elegy for the first half, and a summoning of strength in the second, as the narrator contemplates a possible, ultimate escape. It could be state-sanctioned violence: the way guitarist/singer James Hetfield growls “back to the front” on the beyond-jaundiced “Disposable Heroes” carries the most authority of anything here. Control could even beas it has been to untold men throughout the centuriesa cloak that lets you pass through walls: the ponderous, Old-World acoustic intro of “Battery” is almost a joke: a grenade tossed from the tank. Hetfield rips off gleeful iambic trimeters, galloping atop his breakneck thrash riff like one of his beloved Horsemen. He is Bo Jackson on a juggernaut cart; he is a New Year’s bottle rocket headed straight for Jeremy’s face.

I got to college, and I guess I was free. The dorm I was in freshman year had a T1 line, and I downloaded every recommended track Allmusic threw at me. Many nights, I’d walk to my friends’ apartment across the campus golf course, stone sober with a Wilco CD in the player, or maybe a mix with Okkervil River and Lynyrd Skynyrd. I had forsaken metal. My old friend and co-workerthe closest thing to a hesher in my lifeenrolled at a Christian school in the Southeast. I’d shoot pool at Poets and groan when someone chose “Master of Puppets” on the jukebox. The fuck are you doing, playing an eight-minute song at a bar, I’d think, pumping my heel at Lars’s crashes in the chorus. I’d usually end up picking the poppiest thing in the jukebox, which was “Groove Is in the Heart.”

To a man, each member of Metallica was brought to the harder shit by a family member. Kirk was a horror freak until he started raiding his brother’s record collection. Cliff grew up practicing the piano, but his brother Scott died at 16, and he declared, in way of dedication, that he’d become the greatest bassist. James played piano, toohis mom sang operabut his brother David was a drummer, and when David was in college, James was free to raid his Sabbath collection. Even Lars, an only child, caught the bug after his father (a professional tennis player and polymath) got him a ticket to see Deep Purple in Copenhagen. Lars moved to the States for the sake of his budding tennis career, but metal won out, as it does.

I was my parents’ first child; my brother followed soon after, and I was perpetually checking his notes. I bought two Semisonic records because he’d caught “Closing Time” on the radio and thought it was worth mentioning. (I bailed on buying the single because it had a cover of a song I didn’t know called “Erotic City,” and I was in a Borders with my dad.) He became our friend group’s prophet of ska and reggae, due in part to the Supertones, a Christian third-wave act who opened one album with a brass-boosted nick of the “Creeping Death” riff.

It’s so much work to summon and corral these memories. My recall isn’t great. Maybe that’s why so many of my high-school purchases were poppy CD singles like Madonna’s “Don’t Tell Me” or “Ms. Jackson” by OutKast; why I’ve been assembling massive playlists from the 1960s studded with the oldies hits I remember from three-hour car rides to see our grandparents in Kissimmee. My son could be soothed to sleep, once upon a time; since I can’t remember the full lyrics to more than a handful of songs, I would improvise these fake doo-wop progressions, tangles of aaas and daas and doos until he finally fell asleep. My wife told me he had responded to “Friends in Low Places,” so I spent a few weeks rocking him to a best-guess hash of all three verses. He’s over all that; now it’s shushes and screams and silence. What music comes is for me; I’ll move to the bedroom and pull out my phone, auditioning playlist cuts in the dark, waiting to hear whether bedtime took.

Puppets was every bit the triumph the band wished; they moved to the vanguard of thrash metal, and Ozzy inked them as openers for the American portion of his Ultimate Sin Tour. When that concluded, the band headlined a series of European dates. It was on the way to Copenhagenagain!that their bus flipped, crushing Cliff. Dumb shit like that, you can’t control. But your record’s shifting units that Death Angel could only dream of, so you keep going. You created something, you gotta keep it alive.

I got back to metal. I used to joke that I needed to seek out the harshest shit possible so my kids couldn’t pull rank. Brutality’s its own reward, though. So I’ll call up some d-beat or grindcore or funeral doomjust for me, and usually on a stranger’s recommendation. In the last couple years, my favorite branch has been atmospheric black metal. Synthbeds stretching like spiral arms, while underneath, the rest of the band howls about their insignificance. Existential wonder punctuated with full-body tantrums: I can’t imagine a better soundtrack for a baby.

—Brad Shoup

#168: Elvis Costello, "My Aim is True" (1977)

Declan Patrick McManus is an angry young man. That’s what everyone says about him. He looks like the new intern at some father’s accounting firm (not surprisingly, he worked an office job at a cosmetics company and later worked as a computer operator in Bootle), but it is the seventies, and he is angry. He is not angry the way that men will be angry in 1999—those men will implore each other to break stuff. Declan Patrick McManus isn’t interested in breaking stuff. No, Declan Patrick McManus is a different type of angry young man.

*

Declan Patrick McManus says in the mirror, “I am not angry.” A tiny voice inside of him says, “You are nothing but anger.” McManus says, “I’m a musician. I work day jobs. I do ok.” The voice inside of him says, “Look around. You are an absorbent paper towel sopping up the world around you and letting it rot inside you.” McManus says, “You are part of me. You must be right.”

*

So, Declan Patrick McManus stopped being Declan Patrick McManus. First, he traded his true last name, inherited from his father, for Costello, a pseudonym used by that same father for a 1970 cover of the Beatles’ “The Long and Winding Road.” A little later, he traded his first name for Elvis Aaron Presley’s, the King of rock and roll. Elvis Costello has no middle name. I don’t know if he took his look from Buddy Holly, or if he just always looked that way, but still, when he kicked off his career in the UK as Elvis Costello with the single “Less Than Zero,” he looked like Buddy Holly.

*

Elvis Costello says to Declan Patrick McManus, “Is my middle name Declan?” McManus says, “You have no middle name.” Elvis Costello says, “Why not?” McManus says, “You’re not real.” Elvis Costello says, “Of course I’m real. I am everything.” Then, after a beat, Costello says, “Who needs a middle name, anyway?”

*

Now, in 1977, Elvis Costello is an angry young man. Maybe Declan Patrick McManus never was that angry? Who are we to speculate. But it is 1977, and Elvis Costello sings songs about emasculation and failed relationships and government corruption and greedy tax men and obsession. Those songs are collected on a record called My Aim is True. He sings, “Once upon a time, I had a little money / Government burglars took it long / before I could mail it to you.” He sings, “And I'm doing everything just tryin' to please her, / even crawling around on all fours.” He sings, “Oh I know that she / has made a fool of him.” He sings, “They think that I've got no respect / but everything means less than zero.” He sings, “I’m not angry.”

*

Declan Patrick McManus know that when Elvis Costello sings “I’m not angry,” he is clearly lying. The song seethes, a whispered voice repeats the word “angry” through the verses, and Costello’s vocals smolder. McManus says, “You’re a liar. You’re angry.” Costello says, “Of course I’m angry. I’m using irony.” McManus says, “Oh.” McManus says, “You seem really angry though. At all of those women and government officials, I mean.” Costello says, “Don’t be a dolt.”

*

And then Declan Patrick McManus begins to notice something else about Costello’s lyrics. He notices lines like, “He's such a drag / He's not insane / It's just that everybody / has to feel his pain,” describing the emasculated protagonist of “No Dancing,” and “I think I've lived a little too long / on the outskirts of town / I think I'm going insane / from talking to myself for so long,” from the point of view of the broke, anti-tax narrator of “Blame it on Cain,” and “I tried so hard just to be myself / but I keep on fading away / and then the lights went out, I didn't know what to do / if I could fool myself, then maybe I'd fool you.” McManus says, “What are you really angry at?” Elvis Costello says, “Like you need to ask.” McManus says, “What do you mean when you say, ‘I keep on fading away’?” Costello says, “Don’t you know?” McManus says, “…” Costello says, “You know. I know you know.” McManus says,

*

In the years to come, Elvis Costello would get banned from Saturday Night Live for changing songs, cutting off his band during “Less Than Zero,” and sliding into “Radio, Radio.”. This was before My Aim is True was even available for sale in the States, and before This Year’s Model was available anywhere. Lorne Michaels reportedly gave Costello the finger for the duration of the performance. Two years later, during an argument with Bonnie Bramlett and Stephen Stills, he referred to James Brown and Ray Charles as a “jive-arsed…” and “blind, ignorant…”, respectively, with the ellipses standing in for that most loathsome of racial slurs. He hadn’t heard from Declan Patrick McManus for quite some time, but as a brawl broke out in the bar that night, Elvis Costello thought he heard McManus’s faint voice say something that he couldn’t quite make out.

*

Regarding the incident with Stephen Stills and Bonnie Bramlett, in a 2013 interview with ?uestlove, Elvis Costello said, “I heard these words come out of my mouth and there was a bar fight. It should have never gone any further than that because it was an idiotic—but it’s been in my biography ever since….Despite everything else that I’ve stood for, that’s still mentioned. And some people, in the Twitter/Facebook era, are going to read that. And when you’re in a group that you don’t know, I don’t know whether you know that about me. Or whether other people in the band know that and make assumptions. ‘Oh, this guy’s actually got a white hood in his closet somewhere. He’s actually a secret member of the Klan.’ It’s upsetting. It’s upsetting because I can’t explain how I even got to think you could be funny about something like that. Like I said, I was 25 when that happened. I wasn’t even 25….I’m sorry. You know? It’s about time I said it out loud. You know what I’m saying? Because I know, I know in my heart what—people are curious, people are curious. Even now I see reactions to this record, people going, ‘Well yeah, but they don’t know that about him.’ Well, fucking ask me then.” There’s that anger, still. At least he apologized.

*

Of course, Angry Young Men can’t be Angry Young Men forever. Some grow into Angry Old Men, and some mellow. Elvis Costello landed somewhere in between. In 1998 he released an album of orchestral pop songs co-written with Burt Bacharach, But even that album’s final song, detailing the end of a relationship for reasons unknown, includes the repeated line, “I want him to hurt.” There’s that anger, bubbling up from the album’s strings and horns. But who is the anger directed at? There is no other “he” in the song? Is it a man who the song’s persona’s love interested ran to? Or is it the speaker himself? More of that self loathing. Or is it someone else entirely? Is it Declan Patrick McManus? Where is he, after all of these years? In public life, there is only Elvis Costello, still angry, but more quietly so. And Declan Patrick McManus, what has become of him? Maybe he’s still a name on tax documents, an abstract idea of a man listed on a passport, a distant memory on a birth certificate and on medical records. But otherwise, he’s gone. But Elvis Costello, he is forever, as is his anger.

—James Brubaker

#169: Bob Marley & the Wailers, "Exodus" (1977)

The answering machine blinks. I have three unheard messages.

Two are from Turner, reminding me about Aesop’s appointment. Twice. I guess it says something about me that he felt once wasn’t enough.

Turner is my blind pony Aesop’s vet—he was the first of six vets who said Aesop had a shot at a comfortable life. He’s been making the forty-minute trek to Chincoteague from the mainland twice a week for over a year now. Eventually it got so tense that I couldn’t even go into the barn with Turner. I guess Aes could sense the want between us, like it had grown its own body. An unfamiliar thing in his space. Something detectable without sight. Aesop snorts a pre-buck warning breath when we were both in there. Now I stand on the other side of the barn wall during the appointments, eavesdropping on horse whispers, but listening, mostly, for Turner’s voice.

He finally asked me out last fall, but what that meant to him was coming over every few Friday nights with Won Ton soup and Blockbuster rentals. Depending on the movie, we’d make-out a while. It usually felt like it was going somewhere, but his hands never dropped past the small of my back. Every week I’d tell myself that it was finally going to happen. I even started wearing skirts. But when the hem would ride up my thigh, he’d either pretend not to notice or flatten it out.

He’d say, “just rest, Rox.” Like that is what I need, more rest. People always say that. But sick people don’t want to be told to rest. Instead of wondering, quietly, restfully, if I am going to die, I’d rather be pushed, hard, to the edge of my life.

*

The next message is the scheduling nurse from Dr. DeSouza’s office. She has a stuffy nose. She reminds me, like I don’t know, that I skipped my last two labs. That Dr. DeSouza would really like me to come in. Her sniffles make the message seem more serious. It sounds like she’s been crying. I play it again and again, imagining that she is pleading with me to preserve myself.

I go on the porch and wait for Turner, digging my hand into a bag of birdseed. Cicadas pulse as I stare at the barn, trying to ignore the pull. Turner’s car jerks into my driveway and I pull my hand out of the bag, shaking off the seeds stuck to my palm. He looks different, smaller, in his silver sedan.

He hasn’t seen me yet—he’s finishing off a hamburger. He takes a huge bite and nods along to the reggae rattling his windows.

Turner looks up. I wave and step off the porch. He rolls down the window, still chewing.

“Did we have an appointment?” I call. My sandals kick gravel up at my ankles.

He rushes to swallow. “Didn’t you get my messages?”

“No, did you call?” I cock my head, mocking him.

Turner smiles. “How are you doing?”

“Well, I was thinking about biking to Assateague.”

“I’ll drive you.”

After Turner examines Aesop and shoots him full of medication, I follow him back to the car. He moves the McDonald’s bag, the Exodus CD case, hand sanitizer, and a few library books off the passenger seat. I wonder how long it’s been since he’s had someone else in this car. When he clears off the seat, I sit down, peeking at the books in the back. Two of the three are about learning to fold origami and the other is one called Understanding Equine Neurology.

Turner must take that Bob Marley CD from truck to car to truck. Or have two copies. Neither option is good. I’ve never heard this song. That’s saying a lot, here, too. Chincoteague booms with reggae. I don’t know how it happened—the craggy Virginia island is less than 10 square miles, composed mostly of white, gruff maritime men, decoy carvers and people who run the small shops that support them. Chincoteague pretends it’s Caribbean, only without the always-warm beaches and fresh mango. But, this song isn’t one of the typical anthems the oyster fishermen sing along to at the bar. It’s more like a reggae lullaby.

Turner’s speakers crackle a little, but I can still make out the lyrics. He sings along in an attempted Jamaican coo. “I want to give you some love, I want to give you some good, good lovin’.” He isn’t talking to me, but for a flash, I am comfortable with the idea of being loved by him.

I laugh. “Don’t quit your day job.”

He stops singing.

“I was just kidding, Turner.” I try to sound sincere, but I am not sure how it comes out. I’ve heard that my voice is whetted. Biting.

Turner turns the radio off and wets his lips.

“I wasn’t trying to make fun of you,” I furrow. “Seriously.”

He doesn’t say anything and I clasp my hands and stare forward as we pass a block of colorful dilapidated shacks, some boarded up, some still lived in. We miss our turn to the bridge, but I don’t say anything, afraid it will sound more critical than I mean. It’s never easy for me with Turner, soundtracked either by Bob Marley or loaded silence.

August’s afternoon sun tries to throw off its gray cover, but the sky just barely brightens. Turner clears his throat and turns the music back on, changing the song to the one I especially hate—the one about heathens.

“So,” he starts, “when is the last time you’ve been to the doctor?” It’s amazing, the way he is able to ask caring questions with his voice emptied of care.

“It’s been a minute."

I sit staring out the window, so out of sync with him, this record’s promise of exodus, this island’s pastel bungalows, the tourists and their pony paraphernalia.

When the song fades out, the silence between tracks is so loud.

He drives for another minute before I say, “Maybe we should just turn around.”

“What?” Turner looks over. “Why?”

“I just realized I should probably.”

“Probably what?”

“Turn around. We missed the turn.”

“Why didn’t you say anything?”

I shrug. “I thought you knew how to get there.”

Turner looks over his shoulder and flips the car around. I stare at my feet where a lopsided origami bird has been rejected.

I pick the bird up and sit it on my palm. It tips over. When I try to straighten it out, it tilts again, a wing leaning against my fingers. I think of Aesop, slumped against the stall, limp, crumpled.

He’s close to the turn for Assateague, but instead he turns onto my street. When we get to the house, I get out of the car and Turner pulls away.

I stand there in the dust of the gravel. Things can sour so quickly and I’ve never figured out how to turn it around.

I have this memory of Dad playing “Take Me to the River” by Talking Heads on the car radio. His David Byrne impression always cracked me up. He watched me laugh in the rearview mirror as he jerked the lyrics out. Mom couldn’t take it. She’d just gotten her perm flattened out and colored a flat, lifeless brown, cropped at her ears. I loved her hair. It was big and wild. I felt like I could never see all of it, all of her. Like she was a woman full of mystery, forty-something years of secrets sleeping in her curls. And of course Dad loved it, too—he must have. She had always been that person to us. We needed our anchor.

She turned the music down, saying it had been fifteen minutes and he hadn’t even mentioned her hair.

“Looks good.” He stared straight ahead.

“I don’t need you to lie if you don’t like it.”

Dad was silent. Then she barked, “But I guess it would be nice if you’d say something.”

She couldn’t help it, I guess. Happiness was still too hard to bear. But once our lives had been so good it seemed unnatural. There was a time when we knew how to be happy.

Dad would take Jamie and me to the top of Shadow Mountain in snowstorms, showing us the way our rippling valley looked under its white blanket. My mother would make us hot chocolate and have a warm bath ready when we stripped off our snowsuits.

Mom and Dad would dance to the strange songs that reminded them of meeting. They’d flail to Frank Zappa and Thomas Dolby and drink Jack and Cokes and watch stand-up comedians. They laughed all the time. They made us laugh all the time. Our world was a joke with a million punch lines.

One spring, we were all eating grilled corn and hot dogs in the grassy yard. An ice cream truck siren echoed somewhere in the valley and Jamie and I perked up. With some convincing, my father got in his car and drove off after the tinkling of the song. After what felt like hours to a child, we heard the ice cream truck getting closer to our house. My mother reminded us that even though we were excited, not to forget to thank Daddy.

When “It’s A Small World” stopped and we heard my father’s car door slam, we ran around to the front of the house and saw him unloading boxes of Creamsicles, Drumsticks, ice cream sandwiches, Firecracker popsicles, Klondike Bars, lemon ices, Toasted Almonds and Choco-Tacos. For a second, I thought the ice cream man was moving in with us and his only belongings were the boxes of frozen treats.

When my father finally got the truck unpacked, they shook hands and he drove off without turning his chime back on.

It took us a while to realize that Dad had bought an entire truck full of ice cream for us. Jamie and I kept looking back and forth at each other and then to our smiling parents, just to make sure it was real. I guess when Jamie got sick, my parents used up all the last bit of their magic on trying to make her better.

After almost two years of intensive treatments and surgeries and clinical trials, Jamie went into remission—Mom and Dad almost came back to us. They weren’t quite the technicolor I remember, but they brightened. The color returned to their faces like they had a hope fever. But they didn’t know yet that remission is cancer’s best asset. It hides out, holds its breath, knowing that once backs are turned, it can sneak in, spread out, take over.

After a few months of remission, the cancer was back. Jamie died within two months. Mom stopped reading about vampires and stopped dancing—she never even listened to music, outside of sometimes half-humming along to commercial jingles. Then her curls fell straight.

Even as a kid I wanted to tell my parents it wasn’t their fault, but they seemed to prefer the weariness, letting their bigness shrivel up. They preferred disconnection, the slow emptying of self, to the reality that even after that fever of hope, they couldn’t keep her alive.

I know it’s in me, that whittling away. I don’t know how to stop it.

*

In the house, I put on the TV and pull a blanket over my head. I don’t know what remission’s made of me yet. I like sounds though, suggesting that the world is still going on. People are still laughing, crying, driving cars, and getting angry at each other. People are still together. Bob Marley, cancer-killed, still promises that every little thing is going to be alright.

*

It’s dusk-dark outside when I hear tires pull across the gravel. I’m making a bag of popcorn for dinner, standing beside the microwave, listening for the last lingering pops. Turner is back, lumbering purposefully up the porch steps.

I open the door. His eyes are bloodshot.

“Are you okay?”

“Yeah,” he says, “will you come with me?”

I follow Turner to the car and he’s got that Bob Marley CD on. When “Three Little Birds” comes on, he tears up and I put my hand on his shoulder.

“Don’t cry,” I say.

“I’m not.”

I don’t look at him. I listen, trying to measure the volume and pace of his tears.

“One Love” comes on as we pass onto the mainland. I almost ask him where we are going but when I try to speak, my stomach jerks like a dry heave. Nothing comes out. Bob Marley asks if there’s a place for the hopeless sinner.

We speed past a farm. Some black angus are congregating by the fence. They look glossy, almost wet, in the glow of Turner’s high beams.

“Those cows shouldn’t be out,” I say. “The coyotes will get them.”

“There are no coyotes out here.” Turner sniffles.

I shake my head. “Right,” I say, remembering that I’m far from home, where coyotes kill cows and goats and stray cats whenever the sun slips behind the ridge, where the only water is fresh, where ‘pony’ means a Thoroughbred foal, one that will soon grow tall, wear saddles, hunt foxes.

“I haven’t seen a cow in a while,” I say.

Turner ignores me. Under the headlights, the rocky asphalt looks like fast water. I get hypnotized by the rushing road and the rhythm of the reggae. When Turner slows the car down and jerks into park, I’m still in a trance.

It takes a second to refocus on the stillness and shake my ears of the music, but then I center on the Animal Hospital’s fluorescent sign.

“What are we doing here?”

Turner swings us around back. He opens his car door and closes it so quietly that it doesn’t make a sound.

When I get out and walk toward a door, he grabs my arm and pulls me toward a different one. As he unlocks the private entrance, I half-believe there’s some happy, healthy foal he stole from some nearby farmer that he plans to offer me in place of Aesop. That kind of non-solution he always tries for.

He looks in first and then hauls me into a vacant examination room.

“What are we doing here?” I ask again.

He puts his finger over his mouth, telling me to be quiet. The animal hospital runs 24 hours. Even though it’s nighttime, there are always a few vet techs yawning at the front desk, awaiting emergencies.

Turner locks the door and turns on the x-ray box to light the room. There’s a scan of a small rodent skull on it, but I can’t tell if anything’s wrong. He washes his hands, grabs a syringe and tubes and pulls on plastic gloves. He tells me to go stand in the light.

“Their teeth are so tiny,” I say, looking at the x-ray. Turner quickly ties my arm off with a rubber cord, swabs the crook of my elbow. He pokes into the small swell of blue veins.

“What the hell?”

“Sorry, I usually don’t have to warn.” He puts a full vial on the counter connects a new one to the needle.

“No, I mean, what are we doing?”

He keeps his eyes my blood, which looks black and shiny in this light, like the lacquered fur of the cows.

After he’s done filling four vials, he hands me a cotton ball to push against the vein. On the tubes of blood, he writes Aesop Falk.

“Are you kidding?”

He ignores me and slips out the door. I stand staggered in the eerie glow of the x-ray, holding the cotton ball against my vein.

When Turner comes back, he waves me into a different room. The door warns that we’re going into a radioactive zone. I recognize the tube of the machine perfectly. Maybe I shouldn’t be surprised that it looks exactly the same as the one I’m so used to entering. I’m just an animal.

“Slip all that off,” he rushes me.

“Is this a time machine?”  I drop my jeans and T-shirt on the floor.

“Even that.” He points shyly to my bra.

“Which way am I headed?” I strip the rest off and slip naked onto the cold table.

He points in the direction he wants my body to go, but that isn’t what I meant.

Turner readjusts me in the machine. Though his touch is empty of any intention but to fix my posture, it still excites me when he lays my ankles on their sides, opening my naked hips.

Turner collects the pile of clothing I dropped on the ground and slips into another room. He doesn’t warn me as the machine rumbles to life, but I remember. I take a deep breath and close my eyes. This Bob Marley song is stuck in my head—we got out of the car before it finished. It’s the one that goes:

I don't want wait in vain for your love.
I don't want wait in vain for your love.
I don't want wait in vain for your love.

The tube circles me, starting at my feet and moving up toward my face. Just before it gets there, I stop humming and smile for the picture.

—Elise Burke

#170: The Who, "Live at Leeds" (1970)

Is there anything more exhilarating than an awesome live concert? The band is enthusiastic and absolutely killing it. Meanwhile, you can’t wipe the smile off your face because you’re still in shock that you’re making eye contact with the musicians while holding on tightly to the stranger next to you who is also simultaneously singing along to every word while wiping the tears off their face. Experiences like that reignite the fire inside of you that can sometimes get diminished by our daily routines. Live shows provide us talent, love, and creativity. They also usually involve expensive Miller Lite, awkward dance moves, and dehydration…but it’s worth it. I grew up with a deep appreciation for live concerts, so I know that Led Zeppelin’s “Bron Yr Aur Stomp” should only be listened to from their 1975 Earls Court concert, and don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. I fixate on the craft of live performances, so you can imagine why I agree with every music reviewer ever that calls Live at Leeds the best live album of all time.

My experience listening to live music began in my teen years. When I was 15 I started working at a retirement home as a “dining aide,” or something like that. Basically, I’d give residents their meals and attempt to run away before they got pissed about what they’d ordered for dinner. Working for retirement home kitchens was all politics, man. You want Mary to be able to get a grilled cheese for dinner? Does Betty need her meatloaf grinded up? Unless you want to be grunted at and ignored, you gotta be friends with the cook. Otherwise he won’t give you the time of day. Our cook, Nick, had tattoos and Grateful Dead shirts with corduroy pants and dirty, worn-out Birkenstocks to go with it. He also had a temper and don’t-give-a-fuck attitude, so it was pretty necessary to get on his level. For me, the 15-year-old with braces. side-bangs, and a proud collection of Michael Bublé songs on her mp3 player, getting on his level was one of the best things I ever did.

It didn’t take long before we became best friends. As far as I was concerned, Nick was the coolest guy on the planet and I should have been listening to everything he said. Once, while we both were working a double shift, he took me on a drive where we smoked some of his weed. When we got back I distinctly remember trying to act as normal as possible, but proceeded to knock about five pitchers on the ground and dodge away with my heart pounding like I had just dropped a bunch of grenades. Another time Nick showed up to my house unannounced to take me to bluegrass show in one of the many open fields of southern Pennsylvania. The audience was 99% elderly people in lawn chairs, and Nick and I. We danced barefoot while we passed off a bottle of whiskey and ignored the glances aimed our way.

As Nick would prepare Sodexho-style meatloaf and green beans that the residents would inevitably throw back in our faces later, he would play CDs that he’d burned on his laptop. In the four years that I worked there I quickly learned the discography of Moe., Phish, and Dave Matthews Band. I don’t think it was necessarily the lyrics that made me enjoy the bands, their joy for playing music, and I assumed that was why they ended up with 20-minute songs. Phish literally has a song about someone hitting a possum with their car. Trey Anastasio sings with his low voice, “I was driving down the road one day…someone hit a possum.” In the middle of their long solos they periodically yell “POSSUM!” and that’s the entire song. If you’re not looking up this song on Spotify as we speak I’m not quite sure what’s keeping you.

When I was 16, I went to my first real concert to see DMB. I’ve been consistently going to their live shows ever since. The only way I can describe their live shows is magical. The audience is like family. All of those feelings come back up when I listen to their Central Park Live album. I will listen to their live albums over their studio albums any day, because hearing them live is what their music is intended for, in my opinion. Just a heads up though, don’t listen to their live stuff if you don’t have a fast forward button. “Don’t Drink the Water” doesn’t really start until three and a half minutes inI checkedbut the other 13 minutes are totally worth it.

All this is to say, the talent of the Who, four men who all individually look like English professors in a coming-of-age film, blows all of these other jam bands out of the water. I know I would have been at a Who concert back in the day. They didn’t add the additional 27 songs performed at this concert until a much later edition. Maybe they did that to make sure we could handle it.

You can tell from Live at Leeds that The Who put an incredible amount of work into having a wonderful live album, full of energy and dedication. There’s nothing like a fifteen-minute performance of “My Generation” to make you feel the energy in a live show. This jam…is the jam of all jams, it is packed with guitar melodies that transition into some of their other songs like “See me, Feel Me”. If someone let me know that they finally got their teleportation device working and asked me where I wanted to go, it would be a simple request. The big ol’ University of Leeds on February 14th 1970 for “My Generation”. (In fact, if you were dating someone in February of 1970 and they DIDN’T take you to this concert for Valentine’s Day, they were never enough for you.)

Live at Leeds takes me back to a time when live albums added a carefree, joyous vibe to my long shifts at the retirement home, but it took my appreciation for live music even further. Though the jam bands like Phish and Moe made me happy; it wasn’t a music genre that I was blown away by, and didn’t have lyrics that I connected to. The Who changed that for me. Their live album gave me joy, but it also always reminds me of the obsession with rock music I developed as teenager, and still hold today. When I listen to “Fortune Teller,” I fixate on Keith Moon killing it on the drums. “Young Man Blues” flaunts Pete Townshend’s guitar style that differentiates from anyone else of their time. Their talent creates a sense of awe as much as it does glee. Let the energy of the jam feed into my soul and make me immortal. Let it enter the tears of joy that would inevitably be falling from my face and put an end to all droughts. Is that so much to ask?

—Jenn Montooth

#171: The Byrds, "The Notorious Byrd Brothers" (1968)

My brother invites me over for a beer after he is kicked out of the band he’s been a part of for the past five years. He lives with his wife and their two little girls in a sprawling, five-bedroom house in one of those new subdivisions where all the houses are one of three prototypes, and as I drive over, I try to remember the names of the other band members. My brother plays bass guitar, and the band has four other members, but their names are lost to me.

Trish greets me with a peck on the cheek when she answers the door, my one-year-old niece perched on her hip. “Thanks for coming,” she says.

“Of course.”

“He’s in the den,” she says. She hoists the baby higher. “He’s been there all evening.”

“Okay,” I say.

“I think he was crying earlier,” she says. She leads me through the house, past the newly-redone kitchen, the polished banister of the staircase, the framed family photos that line the hall. The baby, my niece, watches me solemnly over her mother’s shoulder. I make my eyes wide and open and close my lips like a fish, but she doesn’t smile.

Trish sticks her head in the den. “Jonah’s here,” she says. There’s a grunt, and she turns to me and shrugs. “Good luck,” she says.

My brother is lying on the couch watching a muted commercial on TV. A child stands in the rain, face turned upwards, tongue out. The shot moves to a close-up of the child’s rain boots, the splashing mud as he stomps one foot in the puddle. Then it zooms out, and we see the mother watching the child through the window, the smile on her face. Letters fall into place. It’s an ad for life insurance. My brother snorts.

“Want a beer?” he asks and opens one for me.

“Thanks.” It’s warm, and I grimace. I sit next to him. “Sorry, man,” I say.

“Fuck,” he says. “Yeah. Thanks. I guess.” He finishes his beer and opens another.

“You want to talk about it?” I ask. He shakes his head.

In some ways, it’s surprising my brother hasn’t been kicked out of the band sooner. My older niece leaves her kid magazines lying around the house, the pages open to all sorts of half-finished activities: word finds, word jumbles, scribbles over the pictures. If my brother were in the magazine, he’d be in the panel titled “What’s wrong with this picture?” My brother was the newest member of the band, the only one not to have attended high school with the others, the only one with a family, a corporate job. He was the one who kept them from becoming a stereotype. Without him, they’re just four middle-aged guys who were too committed to their music to do anything else, but not quite committed enough to make something of themselves.

“They said I wasn’t available enough,” he says. “I was too busy, with work and the kids.”

My brother has often said that I’m too harsh on the band, that they’re good, but also happy with what they are. He has often said that they have no wish to make it big, to sign with a label. He says they’re just five guys doing what they love, and who am I to judge them? He’s probably right, but as I watch him take another swig of warm beer, and I see the way his fingers tighten around the bottle, like he could break it if he tried, I feel justified in every unkind thought I’ve ever held toward the band.

As a child, I used to believe that the world was wide open to me, that I could do anything, be anyone. My brother and I used to make plans when we were little. We’d be architects and design the tallest building in the world. We were going to be marine biologists in the Great Barrier Reef. We would be a two-man band, traveling around the country performing. Maybe it’s better that we never imagined instead the very ordinary futures we’ve both ended up with. Maybe it’s better that we thought we had more of a choice.

I sometimes joke to my friends, when I’ve had one or two too many, that my brother has it all. The high-paying job, the house in the suburbs, the wife and kids. Even the band, I slur, and they wince and nod and offer to drive me home.

I realize that my brother has set his beer down and is hunched over, his head between his knees, his shoulders heaving. He’s making awful gasping sounds, and I reach over and lay my hand on his back.

“I can’t believe it’s over,” he says. “I just can’t believe it’s over.” He straightens up and wipes his eyes, though they aren’t wet.

“You could find another band,” I say. “Or work on music yourself. Lots of people have gone solo after being kicked out of bands.”

“Who?” he says. “Name one.”

“John Lennon. Paul McCartney. Hell, any of the Beatles.”

“They weren’t kicked out,” he says. “The Beatles disbanded. There’s a difference.” He bends over again. “This isn’t the life I want,” he says. The beer in my hand feels suddenly colder. I turn, half expecting to see Trish hovering near the entry to the den, but she’s nowhere in sight.

There’s a story my brother once told me about the Byrds, a band I always thought to be mediocre at best. When they began recording their fifth album, The Notorious Byrd Brothers, the band consisted of four members. By the time the album was finished, only two of those members remained. The drummer quit partway through the recording sessions, then returned to finish the album, only to be kicked out upon its completion. Shortly after the drummer’s (first) departure, the band fired the rhythm guitarist, and replaced him with a former Byrd, who had previously quit the band due to his fear of flying. This replacement remained with the band for just three weeks, my brother told me, before quitting once again as a result of his inability to board a plane.

When my brother told me this story, I found it ludicrous, and I still do. I thought it strange that after losing half the band, the Byrds could still be considered the Byrds. It doesn’t matter how many times my brother explains to me that a band is more than just the sum of its members. I may never understand it. I want to explain this to my brother, tell him how without him, his band is no longer the same band, how something core to its existence is gone, fundamentally changing the band’s sound. I want to tell him this, but I don’t, because I know it would mean nothing to him.

A sound floats down from the second floor. It’s Trish, singing to one of the girls. My brother lifts his head, listening.

There’s something I should say now, something about duties and responsibilities, but also about dreams, and when you cling to them and when you give them up. I should say something about stability, about wisdom, about sacrifice. But I have never loved anything the way my brother loved his band. I have also never loved anyone the way he loves Trish and his daughters. I am in no way qualified to comfort him, to help him through what can only be seen as a run-of-the-mill mid-life crisis, albeit on the early side.

I pat my brother’s back. His spine is knobby beneath my palm. Somewhere upstairs, Trish stops singing. On the television, the commercials fade away. The Wizard of Oz is on. The Wicked Witch is dispatching her monkeys. “Fly, my pretties,” she’s saying, though the sound is off, and the monkeys take to the air. “Fly! Fly!” The beer bottle slips from my brother’s hand, landing with a muffled thump on its side. My brother stares as the liquid begins to soak the carpet. I go into the kitchen and return with a roll of paper towels. I lay them over the damp spot in sheets. “There,” I say. “See? Everything’s fine.”

—Emma Riehle Bohmann

#193: Green Day, "Dookie" (1994)

I don't think I've felt like I wasn't faking something, at least to some degree, since I moved to Washington, D.C. over a year ago. I left at the height of a neurotic episode that partially upended my life and was then thrown into the city’s perpetual rat race of the worst sort. Things that would generally be considered casual hangs have turned turn into unsought networking occasions, and, thanks to the bounty of things to do in the district, every event to which I reply “interested” on Facebook is a direct reflection upon my tastes, priorities, and ultimately my value as a person. It’s so easy to want to be everything at once when everything seems to be at your doorstep. It’s infinitely harder to be any of it. In a city demanding forward momentum and clear vision of yourself and your future, I perpetually feel like a pretender, a thief.

There was no worse thing to be at my middle school than a poser. I’m from a touristy area, meaning the school’s social structure was almost environmentally wired against interlopers, shoobies, and fakespeople who would seek to claim ours (our beach, our locals-only jokes, our mini-golf courses) as theirsa predisposition that extended to judgment of pretty much everyone on pretty much anything. This was the early 2000s, the golden age of the internet; it had been around long enough to be a reliable resource but was still an almost unfiltered frontier, filled with the sort of deep-cut knowledge of things that was once only accessible through in-person fan clubs and physical encyclopedias, now available with the right search string and the click of a button. Anyone could be an expert on anything instantly, if they knew where to look.

I always want to be well liked but, even moreso, I want to seem intelligent. I’ve learned to temper this as I’ve grown, but the mix of social pressure and adolescent emotions when I was in middle school meant that I, more often than not, was an absolutely insufferable know-it-all who frequently knew little. This was also around the time I was beginning my love affair with angsty music, and around the time Green Day released American Idiot. The album, though not a return to form (it was a starkly different album, structurally and sonically, than anything the band had ever released), was a return to popular acclaim. By early 2005, their slick guitar riffs and infectiously guttural vocals were almost literally inescapable. By all measures, they were successful; by fans’ measures, they had sold out. To have known them before they were famous, then, was a badge of honor; no one wanted to be a bandwagon fan who only heard of them from the “Boulevard of Broken Dreams” video.

The easiest way to fake your way to Green Day fandom was to profess love for songs from Dookie, which was, up until that point, their most popular and successful album (as well as the one that branded them as sellouts to their original California punk fans at 924 Gilman Street). “Longview” is now heralded as a standout from that early era of pop punk, and “Basket Case,” a track explicitly chronicling an adolescent breakdown and suburban ennui, still inspires scream-alongs whenever it’s played at the right audience. Dookie peaked at number one in 19 countries and eventually went diamond. It was also released in 1994; I was barely two years old when “When I Come Around” came around and ensured that Green Day had evolved from specters of California garages to fixtures at multinational franchised record stores.

But, thanks to the fact that we were all 12 when American Idiot was released, an album that was in fact mainstream to an adult fan seemed like a relic to those in my cohort. We had to seek it, or be told about it, or otherwise earn it through scouring Ask Jeeves results and primitive versions of Limewire. Instead of American Idiot, handed to us over the airwaves and on TRL, we had to work for Dookie, and being cool was the return on investment.

I had never heard of Green Day when American Idiot saturated the airwaves (outside of the few chords of “Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)” that inevitably played every so often on soft rock radio), but I wasn’t about to let anyone around me know that. I threw myself headlong into assuming jilted, wildly inaccurate authority on the band. I tried to wax poetic on Billy Joe’s lyrical intentions (missing the very specific and obvious political commentary entirely in favor of a personal narrative) as well as his personal life, and asserted that I knew the band’s history as if it were my own. This was betrayed when I, in relative private and trying to sound hip to my middle-aged mother, claimed that Green Day had been nominated for the Best New Artist Grammy, to which she replied, “Really? I thought they’ve been around for a while.”

There’s no way I was the only one trying to perform this hollow fanaticism. A boy I knew, aspiring to be a rock star with rudimentary bass playing abilities made up for with a killer smile and requisite floppy hair, would frequently post rock lyrics as his AIM away messages. Some were accredited to their actual writers or performers, but more often than not, he’d sign them with his “stage name,” perhaps innocuously, but nevertheless to the effect of passing them off as his own, including the chorus to “When I Come Around.” Because the song was a megahit instilled in the annals of punk history and frequently spun on the radio, it eventually came on during gym class. Someoneeither myself or a friend; mortification has ruined my memory of this momententhusiastically told our teacher, the coolest one at the school, that our classmate had written the song. She looked at us incredulously but nodded along anyway, giving us the baseless acknowledgement of our own coolness we had all been desperately reaching toward at the expense of the very thing we’d been using to build our cred in the first place, experiencing and knowing anything about Green Day.

It was only after time passed and I recognized that I was drawn to Dookie’s triumphantly irreverent but emotional type of music, a singularly insular, personal phenomenon, that I actually began to meaningfully listen to the album. Nothing hit me harder than “Basket Case”’s frenetic ownership of clearly unbridled mental illness. That track accomplishes an almost impossible feat: control of and amusement at an otherwise all-consuming, debilitating disease, all delivered with a wry attitude and punchy, unbothered guitar chords. In “Basket Case,” neuroticism is not a phantom but an annoying friend at the end of the lunch table; an ever-present companion you learn to live with publicly while privately trying to decode the impulses behind his idiotic shit. Though I did not have names for my various mental health issues as an early teen, their pressures and influences were something I could instantly recognize; hearing someone at once make peace with and minimize them, all while firing off some slick chords, felt like the world had opened up before me. Realizing that music, especially music so deeply entrenched as a status symbol, could be personal and resonant instead of just Cool, was revolutionary. I was spending more time falling down the Limewire rabbit hole and the “Listeners Also Purchased” lists on iTunes, but this time, it was relentless and insatiable and gleeful; this time, it was for me.

Parts of Dookie resonate with me still: the constant undercurrent of anxiety; youthful rebellion that is as electric as it is aimless; a longing for Something Different, almost inarticulable and all the more potent as a result. What stands out most, though, is the unshakeable sense that, under the cocksure and lackadaisical lyrics and garage-band-cool instrumentals, Green Day had no idea what they were doing. Nearly every song, from “Basket Case” to “Coming Clean,” deals with trying to find the Self and practically revels in the impossibility of that task. Dookie stares down the enormous pressure of identity and external perception and snarls in its face.

I don't actively listen to Green Day much anymore (a side effect of growing up and realizing that, for the most part, it is the sort of music middle schoolers would listen to to impress each other), but every so often, “Brain Stew” or “Basket Case” shuffles on while I’m walking home from work. Amidst the shadows of D.C.’s famously low skyline and below the signs for federal bureaus, I pump up the volume and let Billy Joe scream for a few minutes about what it’s like to be unmoored and unashamed of it. I slip back a decade and remember being 13, writing tremendously bad poetry about the drama at school and drama at home while a Green Day music video loops on my boxy TV set.

Do you have the time
To listen to me whine
About nothing and everything all at once?

I am one of those
Melodramatic fools
Neurotic to the bone
No doubt about it!

I headbang as undetectably as possible, I open Twitter, I fire off a self-effacing quip, and for a moment, I forget that the very legions of people and institutions I’m constantly trying to impress are literally watching me. I forget about being cool. I forget about any of it. It’s just me, alone with a song I know by heart.

—Moira McAvoy

#172: Rod Stewart, "Every Picture Tells a Story" (1971)

You stole my soul, and that’s a pain I can do without

Sometimes there’s that moment where you know you need to move on from someone. It’s terrifying, and you really have no idea how you’re going to do it. There will most likely be a lot of breakdowns, mood swings, and accidents along the way. But going through all of it is a lot better than staying in the horrendous rut you’re in. That’s the feeling I get out of Rod Stewart’s “Maggie May”. I picture him waking up before her on a Sunday morning, maybe the night after a whirlwind of arguing and the passionate make-up, all while knowing in the back of his mind how unhealthy it is. He’s unsure of how he’s going to get on with his life, but he’s finally at the point where he’s willing to try something else.

*

I firmly believed that I didn’t need anyone but me
I sincerely thought I was so complete
Look how wrong you can be

A typical day for most of us looks like this: Wake up. Commute. Work. Work. Work. Commute. Groceries. Social life. Hobby. Sleep. Food in there at least eight times.

I think sometimes we take the mindless thoughts for granted. Sure, it can be mundane and repetitive, but it is ultimately very freeing when our minds aren’t consumed by something grueling, like painful love. You’re minding your own business in life when suddenly love hits you like a wave that pulls you under water and shoots you back out into the world. You’re dizzy as hell wondering what the hell happened, and so freaked out that you never want to enter the water again. When that kind of love hits us, our mind begins to look like this:

Wake up; What’s the point. Commute; I can’t believe how many people on this train have wedding rings on. Work; Great, I can’t even focus here. Work; I’ve just been staring at the computer screen for four hours. Work; I wonder what he’s doing right now. Commute; I can’t even listen to music. It all reminds me of him. Groceries; I’m not hungry. Maybe I’ll just get a frozen pizza to eat in bed. Social life; I either want to be completely alone or I absolutely cannot be alone. It depends on the hour. Hobby; What’s the point, he’s not even texting me. Sleep; God, I hope I sleep.

*

When we think of Rod Stewart, we think of his business in the front/party in the back haircut, telling us to let him know if we want his body and if we think he’s sexy. But let’s go back to 1971, when Rod used a lot of mandolin and heartfelt lyrics that make you go “…Whoa. Rod Stewart is making me feel things?” That’s right. Embrace it y’all. Start from the beginning and listen to the whole thing through. Let it take you away.

*

Only if she was lyin' by me
Then I'd lie in my bed once again

This feeling is so raw in the beginning. It is a time of desperation. Being alone is the worst, most unimaginable outcome. You’ve done it before, but you don’t remember how. You don’t want to be in it again. You’ll do anything not to be there again. It doesn’t matter how he treated you or the fact that you’re not right for each other. Any thought other than getting them back is simply not an option.

*

In various styles, including folk, blues, and rock, Stewart’s album Every Picture Tells a Story encompasses all of the emotions involved while moving on with your life during heartbreak.

There are a lot of covers on the album: Bob Dylan’s “Tomorrow is a Long Time”, The Temptations’ “(I Know) I’m Losing You”, Arthur Crudup’s “That’s All Right”, and Tim Hardin’s “Reason to Believe”. It’s a surprising amount of covers for one album, and his own lyrics in “Mandolin Wind” and “Every Picture Tells a Story” prove that he doesn’t need this many covers. But hey, I can’t be mad. He chose some great songs, and I like to think that it tells a story.

*

Someone like you makes it hard to live without
Somebody else
Someone like you makes it easy to give
Never think about myself

We lose our sense of self. We think, since when am I the person anxiously waiting for them to call? I used to be so independent, what happened to me? All of my priorities are suddenly entirely based on this other person. Who even was I before I met them? It takes a long time to piece back together those tiny pieces of yourself that you lost.

*

In ten songs, Stewart takes us on a very relatable journey that makes the experience of listening to this album impossible not to feel both nostalgic and reflective of coming out the other side. Remember that scene in Forrest Gump when Jenny leaves Forrest (again), and the only thing he can do is go for a run that lasts for years to the sound of “Running on Empty” by Jackson Browne? We were all thinking of our own heartbreak during that scene. Every time I see it I can’t help but think, “Ugh, I feel you buddy. Been there. Poor bastard.” I appreciate any art that makes us feel previous pain in a reflective way. The least likely of things that usually feel so far out of reach can make us feel both connected and seen.

*

That's all right now, mama
Any way you do

Then slowly, sometimes hour by hour, you pay attention to a conversation. You write an e-mail. You find joy and triumph in small things (for me, it was successfully making a gravity bong for the first time in years). You realize it’s been ten minutes since you thought about him. You start to feel a little hope that next week maybe you’ll go twenty minutes with a free mind. My latest triumph was learning my favorite breakup song on the banjo. I had to make use of learning all of those lyrics somehow.

—Jenn Montooth

#173: Todd Rundgren, "Something/Anything?" (1972)

“Records to most people just represent twelve songs on a piece of black plastic, but records are really a whole lifestyle. […] My attitude is that I make the music for me, and the people that think like me and want to know what I’m thinking. That’s what it’s for.” – Todd Rundgren, Creem, August 1972
 

Side I

Here I am in our church: the floors are carpeted to absorb the sound of our recitations. Twelve-inch squares of colorful cardboard line the walls like stained glass. The pews are bins of cardboard and black plastic, some of it even smells of incense. A hymn plays on the speaker, deep and droning, like monks saying morning prayers. We bow our heads over the bins, eyes lowered, solemn, circular breathing punctuated by the occasional cough or sneeze. Some of us have heads covered out of respect, or maybe just a bad hair day. We kneel to peek inside the bargain bins. We’re seekers: looking for salvation in used records, this place our temple, where lost souls are drawn, looking for absolution from our wrongdoings, seeking comfort from the grief of heartbreak or the pains of the world, music as healing for $4.99 a pop. We worship at the foot of these icons under “Used Pop/Rock R” – Ramones, the Raspberries, the Roches, Rolling Stones, the Romantics…. This is where I’ll find my chosen god. I begin to speak my mantra in the hopes of finding him there: Todd is god. Todd is god.
 

Side II

Every Todd Rundgren fan I know came to him through a different route; at fan gatherings, each relates his or her own Todd origin story with a personal reverence. I came to Todd through a song on Something/Anything?, but it wasn’t the stellar power-pop of “Couldn’t I Just Tell You” or one of the AM gold hits, “I Saw The Light” or “Hello It’s Me,” though certainly I’d heard them before; it was a pervy romp at the end of side IV called “Slut,” which is most notable for the fact that Edward James Olmos sings backing vocals. The first time I heard “Slut” it wasn’t even Todd’s version: it was Alex Chilton, performing the song with Big Star during their encore at the Brooklyn Masonic Temple in 2009. The next day I visited my favorite used record store on the Upper West Side, a different kind of temple: a crowded little nook manned by an ex-music journalist who loved to regale customers with nuggets of wisdom about ELO and Kate Bush. I found a Todd Rundgren album, Faithful, on a lower shelfI had to kneel to find it, as if in supplicationnot even the one that had “Slut” on it, but I bought it anyway.

This was the moment of my conversion; after listening to Faithful on repeat, then deep-diving into old videos of Todd’s live performances on YouTube, I went back to the record store the next day and, as if in a religious fervor, bought every Todd album that I could find.

I own multiple copies of Todd albums, but just two copies of Something/Anything?. I justify the multiples by calling them “backups”in case one gets scratched, I say. But there is a deeper greed at work, a need to be physically closer to each of them. I want them to be a permanent part of me. I want to have them tattooed on my skin; I want to ingest them like communion. I want to consume them as they consume me, to feel them like God (or the Devil) inside me, flowing through my veins.

It’s a wonder I don’t own more than two copies: every time I come across the album in record stores I have to hold myself back from buying it. The cover of Something/Anything? is deeply iconic: a strong graphic of bright pink flowers with green leaves and stems on a magenta background with simple white lettering. I used to think these flowers were peonies, but then started to imagine they might be carnations. Pink carnations symbolize gratitude. The name itselfcarnationhas the root “carn,” meaning flesh, and I like the idea of this album as a communion of gratitude. According to Christian belief, carnations are said to have appeared on the earth as Jesus carried the cross; Mary shed tears and carnations grew where her tears fell. Peonies symbolize spring and renewed life. There’s another horticultural option: Rose Althea or Rose of Sharon, Hibiscus syriacus. Jesus himself is sometimes referred to as the Rose of Sharon. Hibiscus syriacus is the national flower of South Korea, where its Korean namemugunghwameans “immortality.”

It’s hard to say for certain which they might bethe crucifixion, the resurrection, the everlasting life?

Any of these I could believe in.
 

Side III

Breath holds a sacred role in many religions: ānāpānasati, the mindfulness of breathing in Buddhist meditation; the practice of Sufi breathing; the Zoroastrians, who believe that life cannot exist without Dum, or spiritual breath; even a priest’s insufflation during a Catholic baptism. Breath is often tied to the soul; breath is life.

The songs on Something/Anything? are primal, so deep within me that they live beneath the realm of words; to listen to them is to breathe. The “sha-la-la-la”s of “It Takes Two To Tango (This Is For The Girls)” are my heartbeat; “Torch Song” is all the tears I’ve ever cried; the trembling guitar in “Black Maria” is every deep sexual urge: My eyes they burn; my insides turn. Even “Breathless”the upbeat instrumental that leads off Side II, or “The Cerebral Side”itself is breath.

Sometimes I find myself out in the world, shopping in a grocery store, standing there among shelves of canned beans, stressed and tired after a long day of work but knowing I needed something, if only I could remember what it was. And then “I Saw The Light”so deeply loved by the programmers of radio stations that cater to the worship of nostalgiacomes on the tinny speaker above the aisle, a heavenly voice from above.

A feeling hit me oh so strong; the answer was plain to see: Breathe.

And I can breathe again.
 

Side IV

There’s an iconic scene in Sofia Coppola’s The Virgin Suicidesa film itself in part about religion, albeit the more repressive sidewhere the protagonist and his friends (four suburban boys who have been receiving cryptic cries for help penciled on cards and stuck in their bike spokes) realize that they can communicate with the captive Lisbon sisters via telephone and their record collections. When the sisters pick up the phone, the boys put the needle on Todd Rundgren’s “Hello It’s Me” (Side IV, Track 4). Hello it’s me; I’ve thought about us for a long, long time… The songs are their salvation.

We worship records because they speak for us when we don’t always know what to say, or when we can’t say what we want to. They understand us; they speak to us, too. They’re incredibly personal; we find spirituality in them each in our own way. A song can say everything in your heart; the song seems to come from you and from outside of you all at once. We feel things we can’t always understand. Our eyes they burn, our insides turn. We believe as deeply as is possible with our earthly bodies:

‘Cause I believe it all along
I think I’m gonna love it
I know they won’t believe it

When they finally see the saving grace in me

Records are more than twelve songs on black plastic: they are religious experiences for those of us who feel the need for spirituality in our lives but might not ascribe to any single religion. We are seekers without a roadmap, nothing but a song to guide our hearts. I’ve found solace in Todd albums when I’ve had nowhere else to turn, and so I turn to him again and again. I go back to church, pay my tithing to the man behind the counter for yet another copy of an album I already own so that I might take communion, break bread with Todd and feel these songs in me, their saving grace burning like a holy light. Breath. Soul. Prayer. Salvation.

—Zan McQuade

#174: Bob Dylan, "Desire" (1976)

Back in the kitchen of a dimly lit trattoria on Mulberry St. in Manhattan,  past metal shelves of tomato sauce, cans of olive oil, lemons, and vinegar, beneath the dishwasher’s cigarette smoke, past the crackle and croon of Wolf Man Jack on a transistor radio, and beyond the smell of disinfectant in the mop closet, a gentle rap on a maple door, a password whispered, a palmed-fiver-handshake. The Greek forgery artist, a conjuror and his wood-witch sister, and the ghost of a prize fighter sit down for a card game at a circular table whose smooth green felt is criss-crossed with incantations. One player indicates that they’ve not brought any money, but the dealer kindly holds up one hand and says, “It ain’t necessary,” as their chips—each etched with some faded rune—spill before them as though dispensed from the folds of an invisible purse. Their host turns his head to consult a distorted Mercator map of the Earth hung on the wall, and, thus assured of his task, deals each player one card face down, and names the game. 
 

 

In the spring of 1975, Dylan invited experimental theatre director, lyricist, and clinical psychologist Jacques Levy to join him for a month-long collaborative writing session in Connecticut, where Levy penned the lyrics to several songs that would become the most recognizable on the album Desire, and some of the most narratively cogent in Dylan’s songbook. The satellite orbit, post-beat associative verse that had piloted much of Dylan’s songwriting is in pretty stark contrast to Levy’s comparatively straight-shot narratives on Desire, very especially the record’s bookends: “Hurricane” and “Joey”.

When one thinks of Dylan as a titanic individual talent, the depth of this collaboration, in which Levy is attributed authorship of entire songs on the record, might seem anomalous, but it wasn’t unheard of. It’s interesting to think of it as having come on the heels of Dylan’s ‘74 tour with the Band, with whom he’d beaten a well-trod path of give and take, composition and revision and collaboration over the years. But the Great Flood Tour had not been the cohesive or compelling interchange they’d enjoyed previously. In his pretty damned excellent autobiography This Wheel’s On Fire, Levon Helm describes the tour as having been extremely profitable (it has been alleged that roughly 4% of adult Americans attempted to purchase tickets) but that it was a little short on passion, and that nobody had a real good time. The tour marked the beginning of the end of Dylan’s routine collaboration with the Band that had bookended his pre- and post-motorcycle accident career.

By the time he sat down with Levy, Dylan had begun to conceive of a new musical family for himself, a caravan of troubadours that would extend its collaborative processes onto the stage and into an iconic position within his episodic, career-long rediscoveries and self-inventions. Dylan had started writing “Sarah” and “One More Cup of Coffee” on a trip to Spain where he’d spent time playing with some gypsy musicians, grabbed handfuls of the literal and subconscious messages their music conveyed to him, and proceeded to sprinkle it into his work without compunction. This method of ravenous consumption, theft, distillation, and re-presentation scans as a sort of table of contents to Dylan’s playbook as a whole, and I’m among those who find his brand of synthesis to be entirely natural and endlessly fascinating to unpack.

One wonders how deeply Dylan had formulated the sound he would summon so successfully with the group on Desire, or the depth to which they could invoke duende—the creative spirit of a performance—that “works on the dancer’s body like wind on sand…changes a girl, by magic power, into a lunar paralytic, or covers the cheeks of a broken old man, begging for alms in the wine-shops, with adolescent blushes: gives a woman’s hair the odour of a midnight sea-port: and at every instant works the arms with gestures that are the mothers of the dances of all the ages,” as Lorca would have it.

In June of ‘75, as he was driving through the Village, Dylan spotted a woman with crow-black hair down to her waist walking across the street with a fiddle case in her hands. He rolled down the window and called to her, asked if she could play good. She started, as anyone minding their business would have done—she was on her way to a rehearsal with her latin band—then she recognized him. Scarlet Rivera has described herself as having been a sometimes painfully shy person. At the time she was discouraged by her slow, halting progress in establishing the violin as a relevant, innovative presence in contemporary music. She was concerned that no one understood the instrument’s potential. She was good though, and she knew it. She accepted the opportunity to rehearse with him.

By dawn the next morning she’d traveled with Dylan to his studio; extemporized fiddle lines over early versions of “Isis”, “One More Cup of Coffee”, “Joey”, and “Romance in Durango”; gone with to a Muddy Waters performance where Dylan sat in for a few tunes and took the opportunity to announce that he’d found a new fiddle player. Scarlet took the stage when invited, soloed without hesitation, blew the doors off the joint, and accompanied the entourage till dawn. Within the month she was recording as a founding and critically significant member of Dylan’s new musical family and the gypsy caravan he’d been working toward, the Rolling Thunder Review.

In hindsight, Rivera has described the decisions she made in that moment as a crossroads with mythological import. The effect of Desire makes this assessment sort of hard to disagree with; Desire, as a composition, positively rings with archetypal overtones. It’s Dylan’s most mystically charged record, and it crackles with feminine mystique carried off by Rivera’s fiddle lines which alternately scratch beneath and then swaddle Dylan’s melodies, his sawn harmonica leads, and Emmylou Harris’s and Ronnie Blakley’s harmonies, which buttress and amplify a raw feminine power that is, in my mind, the signature effect of the record’s production. Sonically and psychically, Desire is owned by the women who populate it, none more than Rivera.

Attesting to why Desire is so successful and such a personally significant record to so many listeners, one that routinely appears near the top of attentive Dylan fans’ lists, is as difficult as it is unavoidable. It is an entirely alluring effort. Desire sounds like a mystery. It invites speculation and repeated listening and fairly bleeds with the sounds of pathos, love, remorse, lust. One hears a torchlit ceremony, the chemical wedding of the old philosopher king to his bride. Also: It. Grooves. So. Fucking. Hard. Maybe this can’t be overstated, maybe this needs some explaining, maybe it is as self-evident as the tides.

Rob Stoner and Howard Wyeth form what is among the most comprehensively groovy rhythm sections I’ve ever heard in my damn life. Stoner’s root-deep bass tones sound as though they’ve been thrummed on the umbilicus between the world and the moon, and the recurrent slap-back reverb on Wyeth’s drum kit echoes his deft, propulsive stumbling through some cavern toward the light. These tracks, stitched through with Scarlet Rivera’s silver thread, are, in my ears and chest, sometimes nearly overwhelming to consider. These are the sounds of musicians who—having just been introduced to one another and the songs—barely know the material they’re recording, and must rely on their gut to get them from one side of a tune to the other. Their mantra-like groove, a kind of madness born of the survival instinct, pervades Desire binding together the record’s constellation of narratives —historical biography, fantasy, western, revisionist journalism, late-capitalist lament, memoir. It’s as if we’ve tuned in a radio signal by happenstance, as if we might have jiggered the antenna, smacked the top of the radio, and grabbed a different story because we’re awash in them.

I think this record asks us to pay close attention to one another, though, to consider how the granularity of individual lives fits within an interrelated aggregation of those experiences. Clocking in at eight and eleven minutes respectively, “Hurricane” and “Joey” essentially demand a recognition that a discussion of any one life requires room and time to unfold. Alternately, the dizzying, through-the-looking-glass circumlocutions of “Isis” and “Black Diamond Bay” are as a cloud of volcanic dust, a storm of humanity that can be overwhelming to the point of inciting complacency and malaise. (Seems like every time you turn around / there’s another hard luck story that you’re gonna hear / and there’s really nothin’ anyone can say / and I never did plan to go anyway / to Black Diamond Bay.) Desire demonstrates that this blasphemous and sometimes forgivable impulse to look away must be counterbalanced with utmost care and attention to those around us, and how we walk with one another. “Oh Sister”’s solemn, reverential address of separation—which is always so imminent and always so fearfully charged—is unflinching in its clarity: we may never pass this way again. Time is an ocean, but it ends at the shore, is a pressing message to consider and leads without pause to its own natural conclusion which we all must confront: You may not see me, tomorrow.

—Joe Manning

#175: Carpenters, "Close to You" (1970)

It began with a challenge as they left Memphis, and now Caroline and Davis were playing the Kevin Bacon Game, with their own modified rules, as the car made its way through Mississippi and into Louisiana.

“I bet I can connect him with Clark Gable,” Caroline said.

“In seven people or less this time,” Davis replied.

“Clark Gable and Marilyn Monroe in Misfits...Marilyn Monroe and Jack Lemmon in Some Like It Hot...Jack Lemmon and Michael Douglas in The China Syndrome...Michael Douglas and Darryl Hannah in Wall Street and” Caroline’s speech slowed, and she looked out the window as if the answer would be on a billboard. The billboard they were approaching advertised an adult bookstore off exit sixty. The last few billboards had featured busty women in lace bras, glossy lips agape, looking from their billboard perches at the motorists with heavily lined eyes luring them to their gentlemen’s club like an interstate siren’s song. She found the sexy signs entertaining and not disturbing like the one in Byhalia that looked to be fifty years old and said, “Prepare To Meet Your Maker” in calligraphy that looked as if it came from a Gutenberg Bible.

“You’ve run out of steam already,” Davis said, “you only have two more links and then you’ve run out.”

“Darryl Hannah and Julia Roberts in Steel Magnolias

“Shit, it’s always Julia Roberts...she’s your kingpin.”

“I love her. She’s beautiful.”

“Go ahead, go on and finish.”

“Okay, for the win. Julia Robert and Kevin Bacon in Flatliners. My work is done here.”

“It always comes down to Flatliners,” Davis said, scowling behind a pair of cheap sunglasses he had found. They were gold frames with amber tinted lenses, the type Elvis wore during his later years that were handed out at parties and bars during Elvis Week back in Memphis. She knew he was not wearing them to be ironic, but because he needed sunglasses, and yet somehow could pull it off.

“Are you upset?”

Davis shrugged.

“You’re pissed at me because I used Flatliners?” She reached to the passenger side and shoved his shoulder with her hand, trying to be playful and hoping he wasn’t mad. She didn’t know how to read him yet.

“You use it every time.”

“Then let’s take Flatliners off the table. It can be off limits.”

“Do Clark Gable without Flatliners. You can’t do it.”

Caroline considered this.

“Clark Gable and Marilyn Monroe in Misfits...Marilyn Monroe and Jack Lemmon in Some Like It Hot...Jack Lemmon and Darryl Hannah in Grumpier Old Men,” Caroline paused.

“See, it can’t be done.”

“Hush,” Caroline said, and continued, “Darryl Hannah and Tom Hanks in Splash...Tom

Hanks and Elizabeth Perkins in Big.”

“One more!”

A smile spread across Caroline’s face as she turned her head to him and said, “Elizabeth Perkins and Kevin Bacon in He Said She Said.”

He grinned at her, and she was relieved that he wasn’t angry about her win. His hair was dark and wavy, grown out in a shaggy yet fashionable way; he tucked some of it behind his ear and revealed his cheekbone, which was so pronounced it reminded her of last summer when she finally got to go to Rome and glance upwards and at The David, his chiseled features highlighted by the light streaming in through the skylight of the rotunda that housed him. Davis looked back at her and she returned to watching the road. She leaned up to, almost over, the wheel and knitted her brows together in concentration. She recalled her friends saying that she drove more like a grandmother than a twenty-two-year-old and leaned back from the wheel.

“So how do you know this stuff?” he asked.

“I don’t know,” she shrugged. “I’ve always loved the cinema but never really watched many old movies…just read until a couple of summers ago when I got really sick and it kept me in bed for a few months. Having the TV on was reassuring. I liked Turner Classic Movies and just let it run day and night and by the time I was better I had grown accustomed to it, so I keep it on still, even when I’m not home.”

“What was wrong with you?”

“What? You mean back then? Nothing romantic, just mono.”

*

They were driving the five and a half hours from Memphis to New Orleans because Davis was playing an impromptu gig at a small bar. It wasn’t Caroline’s job to drive Davis around to gigs, nor to guitar tech outside of the studio, but she was being paid extra for this road trip. She worked for the studio as a secretary and audio engineer apprentice where he was recording his second album.

The studio was a part-time job that she obtained for the purpose of living off campus in an apartment, for which her parents refused to pay the rent because they worried she was becoming antisocial. However, the owners of the studio, Jerry and Vic, found that she had a good ear from years of music lessons. They taught her to set up the studio, mic the instruments, tune drums, and tech guitars. Now, slowly but surely, she was learning to use the boards and check levels, and Vic let her record the hobbyists that came in to record something. Vic called them “trust fund musicians,” but after hearing Caroline’s mix of her first session he had told her, “You are a wizard of sound…you actually made this shit sound decent.”

Surprising herself, she loved working in the studio. Everything about the process: the placement of the instruments and mics, the levels on the boards, restringing guitars, even tuning drums. Caroline had won many awards in college, and had applied to several ivy-league schools for her masters in the Classics, yet she thought she might defer a year, if accepted, to work more with Vic and Jerry. She did not know if academia was for her, with audio engineering at least she would have a skill set. Caroline had yet to mention this to her parents.

Caroline thought the studio had a seventies feel, wood-paneled walls (both in the studio and out), carpeting that was probably once the color of an avocado, now dull and brown from being endlessly exposed to a constant stream of cigarette smoke. Gold records hung on the walls along with framed copies of the respective album covers. All of them were recorded here, some she recognized.

She answered the phones, made coffee, and rarely had to type up invoices (the studio wasn’t all that official and the invoices were simple), but, since the studio wasn’t that busy, mostly she just read. There had been a buzz among the musicians when Davis arrived in town, but then again, there were a steady stream of famous musicians that chose to record here over the years. As Vic and Jerry had reminded her numerous times as a selling point when people called about booking time, they recorded things the old way, the way they recorded Elvis or Johnny Cash down the street at Sun to get that rough and muddy Memphis Sound: all the players playing on a two track, no overdubs, with a slight tape delay that produced that quick slap-back doubling sound.

Davis was from New York and didn’t have a car, even though the label he was with would have probably provided one. Instead, he rode a bike around Memphis. Caroline was the only support staff in the studio, and Jerry and Vic worked the boards as engineers when legitimate musicians came into record. She’d overheard them talking with one another about Davis before he arrived to record, and gathered that his first album was a cult favorite, popular among other musicians, but his songs were too long for radio play and the label wanted the second album to be more commercial. He chose to come to Memphis so they couldn’t spy on his progress. Davis had insisted twelve mics for all the players and instruments as well as live recording with the other players. Essentially, he wanted to record one track with no punch-ins or punch-outs. This album would take a while. When she had heard his demands, prior to his arrival, she decided he was a pain in the ass.

*

When Davis walked in for his first session, she was sitting at the reception desk reading and didn’t see him come it. He startled her when he asked her what she was reading, and she looked up, confused because she was still thinking in Latin and not used to being disturbed. He was attractive in that mystical and grubby way that most of the musicians were; they

had a certain Parisian or Continental quality, but perhaps a bit more so in Davis’s case as there was a light and intelligence behind his eyes indicating that he was not impaired as most of the musicians were that darkened the doorstep of the studio.

“It’s Virgil,” she replied, and looked back down at the text. He stood there in front of her desk and she felt his gaze upon her head. His presence was warming, like one of those red lamps they keep fries under at a fast food joint. Her cheeks felt hot and flushed.

“The studio is back there,” she said, not looking up and pointing vaguely to the back.

He leaned over the desk closer to her and whispered, "Oh Muse, recount to me the causes," then walked away. She stared after him with a surprised glance, her head slightly tilted as if she were a dog trying to understand its owner’s words, and her gaze followed him as he walked into the studio. She got up quickly to follow him into the studio to check the mics.

She went to the record store and bought his CD on her way home from work. The liner notes gave a simple bio: he was raised on the outskirts of Los Angeles, no formal music lessons, and after high school he moved to New York and began to gig. He was thirty.

*

When her bosses not so much asked, but told, her to drive him to this gig, she was upset.

“Yeah, I guess this means no reading yourself Greek on our dime,” Jerry said. “You’re gonna have to actually work the rest of the week.”

“Unless they have Greek on tape for the car ride,” Vic said and spit some dip into a plastic Coke bottle. Jerry belly-laughed at Vic’s comment.

“I work plenty around here and you both know it. Why can’t you get one of the session players to do it?” she asked.

“Who in their right mind would want those drunks driving them around?” Jerry said. He and Vic looked at each other and laughed like they hadn’t heard a joke before. Caroline rolled her eyes.

“Besides, our college girl has a dependable car,” Vic said.

“He’s the one who’s paying and he wanted you,” Jerry added while raising and lowering his eyebrows several times.

*

“I mean, the best stories have already been written...long ago. The Greeks. Man, the Greeks. We still only have stories that operate on a number of plots, like thirty or forty, some guy wrote a whole book about it and the Greeks and the Romans are responsible for most of those. English Lit people argue Shakespeare, but c’mon. Poetry, too, it’s all from epic ballads. Doesn’t that bother you? While you are writing lyrics? Singing your songs and knowing that the best stuff has already been written?”

She looked at over at him. Davis was looking back at her, a half smile on his face, and he was not wearing his Elvis sunglasses. His eyes squinted from the afternoon sun, his hair fell in dark waves around his face and neck.

“Well...does it?” she asked, forcing herself to look away from him and back to the road.

“I’m sorry, what are you asking?”

“Hand me that Twix out of the bag,” she said with a sigh and paused as Davis retrieved then handed it to her. She opened the candy bar, took a large bite, and then said with a mouthful, “I mean, Virgil...he’s my favorite. He’s the shit. He must be a tough act to follow.”

As she finished the candy bar the cadence of her car’s tires slapping the causeway over the Pontchartrain signaled to Caroline that the drive was almost complete and Caroline felt a pang of regret about this. The drive and the city was familiar, her uncle lived in New Orleans and her family usually visited once a year. She hoped her knowledge of the city would impress Davis.

She glanced over at him as he looked out the window at the lake and the small fishing camps, houses on stilts, with fishing boats parked on the water nearby. The scenery alongside the interstate became the suburbs of New Orleans which was a strip-mall haven, and then came the above ground cemeteries that reminded Caroline of miniature cities, the crypts in neat rows like houses lining streets stretching across the green ground for acres upon acres. Concrete angels and crosses taller than the cemetery walls decorated the rooftops of the crypts.

“Okay,” Caroline said, “where is it again that you booked our rooms?”

“La Pavilion, but I promised a friend I’d drop by and say hello, so I guess head toward Uptown to their place,” Davis pulled a scrap of paper from his pocket and read the address, “Jefferson and Magazine.”

Caroline noted his odd use of nouns and pronouns and suspected that the friend was a woman. Caroline tried to think of something to say but managed only to nod. The pit of her stomach hurt, and she told herself this was because of the Twix.

Fourteen blocks later, Caroline parallel parked on Magazine and immediately pulled a book from her bag.

“Sure you don’t want to come in with me?”

“Nope, I’m good. I’m at a crucial point and haven’t read this translation yet,” she waived her copy of The Aeneid at him without meeting his eye.

Her eyes drifted over the words of one line repeatedly and without comprehension. After five minutes she saw Davis emerge from the front door of the peach shotgun house with a long-limbed woman with a dark bob and translucent skin the color of cream. Caroline stared, taking an inventory of the woman’s appearance. She wore short shorts with a tank top and a pair of sandals and carried a large straw handbag. She looked artistic, sophisticated, and close to Davis’s age. Like Davis, she looked grubby and Parisian as if she belonged on a beach cruiser bicycle with a baguette and bouquet of flowers in the basket on the handle bars.

The woman got into the backseat and Davis returned to his front seat.

“We’re going to drop Ilene off at work, I think it’s on our way.”

“It’s on the twenty-four-hundred block of Magazine,” Ilene added.

“Sure,” Caroline said, and began to drive.

“Are you the girl that reads all the time?” Ilene asked, and Davis shifted a bit in his seat at this.

“Yes,” Caroline said, watching the road.

Davis and Ilene discussed the people they had in common, people Caroline did not know, and places Caroline had never been. They spoke about Ilene’s paintings and her newest gallery show and her creative process. At red lights she watched Ilene in the rear-view mirror and noted her flawless arched brows and crimson painted lips. Once, Ilene met her gaze in the rearview mirror and something about the way Ilene looked at her was both curious and apologetic.

Caroline knew then that Ilene was Davis’s lover or had been at one time.

Lover. It was such an adult word. Caroline had been with several guys, one in high school and three (maybe technically four) so far at college, but the thought of referring to them as her lovers was absurd and, well, pathetic. When she thought of those sexual experiences, she thought of them as close encounters. Like the time her family went to Mexico and swam with the dolphins: it was okay, the dolphins were nice enough, but it wasn’t like it was on Flipper and that was what she had expected it to be, wanted it to be.

Yet she didn’t think of her sexual exploits often. When she wasn’t at the studio, she led a life of quiet and solitude in the study carrels of the library, the glow of the green banker’s lamp illuminating Virgil, Ovid, and Homer, surrounded by the sweet scent of the decaying books in their stacks, a smell that made her salivate. These past few years in the library with her books and her few friends, most of which were either library workers, professors of classics, and, of course Vic and Jerry, were fulfilling and happy.

Working at the studio this summer or, more specifically, seeing Davis at the studio this summer, confused her. That day she first met him she tore open the excessive packaging of Davis’s CD, Found Melodies, while still in the parking lot of the record store and sat in her running car, AC blasting, listening intently. It was as if John Keats and Virgil had somehow gotten together to write lyrics and found the male equivalent of Edith Piaf to sing them. At her desk at work, her mind wandered from the dactylic hexameter of The Aeneid to the door of the studio and, in it, the artist. He was both bard and songbird. Her life no longer felt as full and her underarms never seemed to be dry anymore.

“Okay,” said Ilene, “this is it, up here.” Ilene leaned forward, sticking her arm in between the front seats to point to where Caroline was to drop her off. Her arm was hairless and slender like a vine. As the car pulled to a stop, Ilene whipped a scarf from the straw bag and, without effort or aid of a mirror, tied it around her head, making a perfect turban. Davis and Ilene kissed one another, but once on each cheek, to Caroline’s relief, rather than on the mouth. Caroline told her goodbye and Ilene smiled at her. This time she was unable to read what Ilene’s smile was telling her.

Ilene got out of the car and walked down the sidewalk, disappearing as she entered a storefront with a window that featured a sad-looking mannequin wearing a yellow dress. There was a heavy silence as the car pulled out onto Magazine and onward toward the hotel.

“Ok, do Greta Garbo.”

She couldn’t look at him.

“She was in movies with Clark Gable,” Caroline said and added, “I don’t want to play anymore.”

*

One night the previous week, Caroline had been doing her daily routine for closing up the studio office. It stayed light so late in Memphis in the summer. The front door of the studio faced west and the late evening sun, beginning to set above the Mississippi, cast the office in a bright-colored haze of pink and orange. The light streaming through the front windows made the dust in the studio office appear and dance in the air. She had traveled many places in the world and yet it always seemed more beautiful here at home, the summers here were like no other on earth: hot sun with the fuzz from the cottonwood trees, white and resembling snow flurries, blowing in the breeze.

She watered the sad potted plants that she had resurrected during her tenure at the studio. In the room with the boards it was dark and she scrunched up her nose as she emptied all the ashtrays, which were filled by the end of the everyday by Vic and Jerry alone with both cigarettes and occasionally the burnt-out ends of joints. The window over the board looked out upon the recording studio and the lights were on, Davis was still inside strumming his guitar, singing and jotting things down on a piece of paper balanced on a music stand. He wasn’t using a mic and she couldn’t hear him playing or singing, it was like watching television on mute. She remained unseen until, leaning on the control board, she hit a button, causing an amp or mic to squeal inside the studio.

Davis stopped playing and shielded his eyes from the house lights while looking at the control room window. Caroline darted out of the control room and to the kitchenette sink and began to rinse the coffee pot out. As usual, Vic had left it on when it was almost empty, cooking the dregs of the coffee into a black soot that stuck to the bottom of the pot. Hearing footsteps, she cleaned this pot as if the task fascinated her; she became a scientist of the coffee pot, scrubbing it and holding it up to see that her work was progressing.

“Was that you at the boards?” he asked.

“Yes, I had to dump out the ashtrays...apparently Jerry has been hitting the ganja again.” She felt him move closer to her, the nerve endings in her body felt as if her hands were on one of those static balls, the type at museums for children that made your hair stand straight on end like a dandelion, rather than on Vic’s nasty coffee pot.

“Are you still reading The Aeneid?”

“Yes,” she said as she put the coffee pot on the rack to dry, then turned from the sink, “when

Jerry and Vic aren’t busting my balls about...”

She looked up and his face was inches from hers. He put his hand on her cheek, cupping it, and she nuzzled her face against his palm. As if it were a reflex, she put her hand on top of his and moved it from her cheek to her mouth and kissed his wrist. Then, as if snapping back from a hypnotic state, embarrassed by her own bravado, she bolted from the kitchenette, grabbed her book bag, and walked out the door into humid dark.

They had not spoken of it since.

*

At the gig, Caroline set up the amps, making sure the Rickenbacker and the Fender were restrung and tuned. After talking to the man running the sound, and listening to the soundcheck to make sure nothing was too hot, Caroline went outside into the balmy air as people streamed inside. She pulled her book from her bag and forced herself to focus on the words, highlight passages, and take notes in the margins, yet every few minutes her mind worked its way back to Davis. There seemed to have been an unspoken understanding between them, an energy between them, an intimacy, and she felt foolish to have thought so. How would she know it if there had been?

She had not known hardship in her life and yet she had not known intimacy of any form, either. Many privileges had been afforded her by her parents and yet she was raised by television and books while her father sold bonds and her mother played tennis at the club. Her only company at home was the housekeeper who smoked Kool cigarettes in the backyard when she wasn’t scouring and scrubbing the house with a rightfully vindictive fervor, and a brother who was into golf, jam bands, and the Republican party. Neither of them spoke to her very often.

When her parents did speak to her, it was to criticize. She hoped each time they approached her that it was to tell her that she had been adopted and that her real parents were the hirsute bohemian couple from the illustrated sex book that she had found in her mother’s scarf box in the seventh grade, but that conversation hadn’t occurred yet. The response to her attempts to connect to them was always a reductive soliloquy by one of her parents, the sole purpose of which to let Caroline know that she was a mistaken fool. For instance, a couple of years ago, Caroline read a book for college orientation, the one that had been chosen for all entering freshman so they would have something to discuss together while doing ice breaker games and trust-building exercises in the quad. It was a memoir about growing up in the shadows of the nuclear generators of Three Mile Island and being a closeted lesbian. Caroline was unable to put the book down, she found it “honest” and “relevant,” just as the blurbs on the cover described it. After reading it, she gave it to her mother to read. Her mother read the book jacket and introduction where the author talked about her current life, living in a yurt in Colorado with another woman, then handed the book back to Caroline. Her mother shook her head and sighed, “This is emotional exhibitionism.”

“It’s about the environment,” Caroline replied.

“Everyone nowadays has to compete with each other over what all they’ve overcome,” her mother said, making apostrophes in the air with her manicured fingers. “It’s the goddamned pain Olympics.”

And yet she pitied her mother, who had her own “pain Olympics” in Caroline’s plain sight. The summer that Caroline was twelve, the turntable at their home was in constant use and her father, a bond trader, was out of the country for work. Her mother compulsively played the Carpenters’ Close to You, with special attention to the title track and “Baby It’s You” while moving the needle past the sad songs like “Another Song.” Caroline endured this with eye rolls, as the album was so dated, but soon knew the words to each song and warmed to it. She loved the country twang that was placed in “Reason to Believe.” The album bothered her in a way that she didn’t know how to explain then. Now she would describe it as being over-produced. Caroline longed to hear Karen’s voice; she felt that the horn sections and strings took away from it. It was almost as if the producer attempted to candy-coat her voice. Karen’s voice soothed her as the drama unfolded around her, but there was something else there, a subtext to that saccharine sweet voice that added depth. A sadness maybe?

Their pool house had been rented that summer by an artist named Hopper Williamson. He had a mattress on the floor and used the rest of the small space as a painting studio. His uniform: jeans and a white undershirt covered in paint drops. He ate canned ham from the can. His only belongings were his art supplies. Caroline’s friends thought he was a “stud,” and Caroline could see why they would say that, but she would never agree.

As Karen sang “We’ve Only Just Begun,” Caroline’s mother would hover at their house’s back window watching Hopper’s shadow paint on a large canvas. Her mother also took sudden interest in swimming in the pool, and traded her one piece for a string bikini. At first, Hopper would briefly came out to talk to her Mother when she swam, kneeling at the poolside, usually with smears of paint on his face. He wore a black bandana on his head. After several weeks, he began to join her in the pool.

After their daily swims, her mother would drape herself in the towel, come inside, and Karen would begin to sing from the turntable. Her mother would make lunch or start to prepare something for dinner in some sort of odd daze, smiling in intervals at nothing. For Caroline, this was disgusting, yet more intriguing than MTV.

One morning, Caroline woke earlier than usual, just after dawn, planning to use the pool before her mother claimed it. She looked out her bedroom window to the backhouse to see her mother kissing Hopper at the door of the pool house, then quickly made her way into the main house. Caroline made a beeline downstairs and nonchalantly poured herself a bowl of cereal. Her mother was startled when she saw her. Caroline smelled cigarette smoke and alcohol on her mother, but the glow on her mother’s face was something she hadn’t ever seen. She hadn’t ever really seen her mother happy. At that moment, Caroline decided to play along.

“We are out of Cheerios. Could you put that on the grocery list?”

Her mother’s shoulders relaxed and she said, “Of course.”

The summer of Karen continued like this until Caroline’s father returned at the end of August. Her mother became distraught, but still swam daily with Hopper while Caroline’s father was at work. From the back window, Caroline could tell that their conversations were becoming serious, tense even.

Hopper moved to Marfa, Texas two weeks later. Caroline’s mother never played music in the house again, and Caroline took the turntable and the vinyl to her room to listen to through headphones. That winter, Karen Carpenter died, and soon Caroline found out what all was hidden in that voice. That voice was art and it prevailed over the attempts to hide the emotion behind it. Her mother returned to her bitter state, but every once in awhile, Caroline would see her mother return from the empty pool house with her lashes wet and eyes rimmed in red.

*

It was nearly three in the morning when they loaded his gear into the trunk of her car and made their way back to the hotel.

After changing into a T-shirt, she sat on the edge of her bed, the hotel linens stiff beneath her thighs. He was in the adjoining room and she wondered if he would go back out or if Ilene would come over here with her straw bag and wrap her milky limbs around him. It was all for the best. Caroline did not want to end up crying into Vic’s ashtray. She immediately began digging in her bag for her Discman and headphones. After dumping the contents of her bag and realizing she did not have her headphones, she belly-flopped onto the bed and covered her head with a pillow that felt as if it had been heavily starched. The pillow crunched as she pressed it around her head. She decided that this arrangement would work almost as well as the headphones as long as she kept the pressure on the pillow throughout the night. As she set the pillow aside to peel back the bedclothes, she heard a rumple as a piece of paper slid beneath the door to the adjoining room.

Caroline walked over to the door and picked up the paper. It was a note scrawled on hotel stationery.

“Virgil opened up for me tonight. He was a tough act to follow. Did he ever work with Kevin Bacon?” it said.

She wrote on the bottom of the page, “I’m sorry I missed that (Virgil I mean, not you). He was responsible for the screenplay of Footloose, so yes, he worked with Bacon.” She slid the paper back under the door and after a moment she heard the lock on Davis’s side of the adjoining door unlock.

Caroline took a deep breath, then exhaled slowly as she unlocked the latch of her door and found Davis on the other side. He held out his hand and she took it.

—Edie Pounders

#176: Aerosmith, "Rocks" (1976)

Ah yes, 1976. There’s not much that I don’t love about this year. It graced us with Blue Oyster Cult, Hall and Oates, Steve Miller Band, and Electric Light Orchestra. Rocky entered the ring for the first time as a mere unknown boxer, Travis Bickle was dubbed a hero, and every child in America pulled a Stretch Armstrong across the house. But in the same year, a 34-minute album that displayed a simple black cover with five diamonds on it emerged into our lives. How does this album the length of a Seinfeld episode (with commercials) stand out from the others?

It blew everyone’s minds with insane guitar riffs.

Rocks encompassed freedom. The band was allowed to play whatever the hell they felt. Most of their inspiration came while using various drugs, but this was their best time, before their health and career were in any kind of danger. Let’s face it, the lyrics on this album are not their strong suit (There’s got to be a more hardcore way of saying “Back in the Saddle”), but let’s remember that this was 1976, when Peter Frampton had a top hit in which he repeatedly asked, “Do you feel like I do? Do you feel like we do?” Poetic words weren’t exactly a top priority. But when you’re Aerosmith and you’re at peak fame with an empowering guitar that blends with Tyler’s harmonies, does it matter? It didn’t at the time, when several of the singles on this album went to the top. This was just the peak of their stardom, before there were any repercussions for doing whatever the hell they wanted. The same year Rocks came out, Steven Tyler appeared on the cover of Rolling Stone, in which Ed McCormack hilariously claimed Tyler looked like Carly Simon’s kid sister. Looking at the cover now, making eye contact with Steven taunting me with his puckered lips, I think he looks like the hot, rock-star version of Ross Malinger (Google him, you’ll see what I’m talking about).

It’s funny. I don’t think Aerosmith is anyone’s favorite band. I’ve never heard anyone say “Favorite band of all time? EASY, it’s Aerosmith. I never take off my 1976 Rocks tour T-shirt, I even wear it under my suit. I don’t wanna miss a thing, am I right?” Perhaps it’s because they had a significant gap in their fame during their rehab stint in the 1980’s, while all of the younger bands who drew inspiration from Rocks took over the fame for awhile. When THAT cycle ended and all the Mötley Crües and Metallicas of the world had their own stay in rehab by the 1990s, Aerosmith came back just in time to give us a couple more chart-toppers. But by that point everyone was like, “Hey, that’s Liv Tyler’s dad! She’s really hot in Fellowship of the Ring.”

Even so, let’s not doubt how famous these guys are. They’re everywhere. One of my middle school teachers would constantly play the classic rock radio station during art class, and it felt like every five minutes or so “Rag Doll” would come on, sandwiched between other the radio classics “White Wedding” and “More than a Feeling”. I swear those three were like the holy trifecta of family-friendly radio throwbacks.

I grew up in the ‘90s just as Aerosmith was having their second wave of fame. We went through triumphs and flukes together. They signed on Alicia Silverstone to their music video, I managed to get my first boyfriend. While I was getting shiny, mouth-invading braces put on my teeth, they wrote “Don’t Wanna Miss a Thing” for the mediocre movie Armageddon. My favorite thing about music videos from the ‘90s is they always had to incorporate movie clips into the music videos, and it inevitably always looked corny. For this video, it’s made to look like NASA’s top scientists are looking at Aerosmith performing instead of a world-ending rogue asteroid. Can you blame them? Steven Tyler looks like he’s fresh out of the shower in this video. I personally think it’s worth a watch, and over 99 million people agree with me.

When I started to feel teen angst, they graced me with “Jaded”, the only song worth listening to on Just Push Play. The desperation in Tyler’s voice when he screeches “My my baby blue” with the moody guitar that transported me into a vortex of emotion that I desperately needed in a post-‘90s grunge era.

To me, it felt like Aerosmith was a hot family friend who you refer to as Uncle, who used to be a rebellious bad boy but suddenly found himself picking out curtains at IKEA and adopting small dogs with his wife. That persona changed after I heard Rocks for the first time.

I first listened to Rocks in 2006. It was exactly what I needed to enter high school with. It was the first time in my life where the blood rushed to my face out of pleasure instead of anxiety, and I channeled those feelings of anxiety, angst, and confusion into a carefree, sick-of-everyone’s-shit kind of attitude. This album transports me back to those days, when my priorities shifted from what people thought of me, to which Led Zeppelin album was better, III or IV? (IV, and don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.)

Even now, just re-listening to “Get the Lead Out” has transformed my walk to the metro. The usual bored, lifeless face I carry on my morning commute now has the confident side smirk of a 15-year-old who just spray-painted a mustache on a billboard. It’s all thanks to Joe Perry shredding it on guitar while Steven Tyler sings “Won’t ya grab my shaker / Got to meet your maker.” In the midst of work stress and the drama that encompasses my twenties, this album whisks it all away and I am suddenly turned into a hair metal groupie fuming with hairspray while wearing an Aerosmith crop top and screaming, “I’ll grab your shaker, Steven!” toward the stage.

There’s no doubt that the guitar solos on this album, along with their rebellious lyrics, inspired all of the big ‘80s heavy metal bands, but this album has its own personality. “Rats in the Cellar” has the harmonies and fast-paced energy of the punk scene emerging at the time, but Tyler makes it his own by throwing in a harmonica solo. We don’t hear harmonicas enough anymore. In the song “Last Child,” they even got Paul Prestopino to join in with his banjo. That would probably be dubbed a rock ‘n’ roll sin in the 1980s, but this again proved that Aerosmith could do whatever the hell they wanted in 1976 and make it work.

“Nobody’s Fault” has the most serious tone of the album, and a very fitting song as we currently find ourselves in the aftermath of one of the worst natural disasters. Their fear of earthquakes taken out in Tyler’s screech of “Sorry, you’re so sorry” and the very real lyrics

Man has known
And now he’s blown it
Upside down and hell’s the only sound
We did an awful job

And now they say it’s nobody’s fault

It’s pretty amazing, right? This entire album feels shorter than “Stairway to Heaven”, and has lyrics that the musicians themselves probably didn’t even remember writing. But the energy that this album formed in 1976 can still give a confidence boost to us 40 years later. It’s easy to feel like the world is out to get us, that we don’t stand a chance unless we’re always following the rules and counting down until the shift is over. I always appreciate albums like this when they give us at least the fantasy of the alternative: What if I say no? What if I talk back? What if I break the rules?

—Jenn Montooth

#177: Funkadelic, "One Nation Under a Groove" (1978)

One of my best friends, Bailey, loves funk with all of her being. “It’s just nasty and raw and it’s this outpouring of cosmic energy and humor and anger and sexual frustration and dirtiness that you just can’t find in anything else,” she says.

When we talked about Funkadelic’s One Nation Under a Groove, she said, “Oh man, that album just grooves in your stomach and your body,” and I didn’t really get it but went along with it anyway. I didn’t want the poetry to seem over my head. But now, going on the fifth day sitting in the library writing and opening blank Word documents and writing and listening to George Clinton’s voice and writing, I get it. When you really get into writing, and I mean really get into it, where your fingers fly over the keyboard or your hands slide over the page, you’re in a groove. And you can’t stop listening, you can’t stop writing, and you’re not you anymore. You’re something greater than yourself, and maybe you don’t fully understand it yet but you’re trying to figure it out.

Listening to Funkadelic is like listening to passion incarnate. The claps and the cowbell and the backup singers who blend into the melody so well you barely recognize them as human—they all come together in a balanced chaos that I don’t really understand but I do, too. It’s the same balanced chaos of passion. Now, I have a lot of passions (just a few days ago I got in a heated argument about how pumpkins are just overhyped squash, for instance), but I’m really, really passionate about two things: writing and kindness.

I think I black out a lot when I write. Something washes over me and then I’ll check my phone and it’s two hours later and I’ve written four pages and I know what they’re about but could not for the life of me tell you what happened around me during those two hours. Every time, I feel the writing in my bones. It breaks my heart and repairs it, over and over again.

The opposite happens with kindness, though. Every few weeks my mom reminds me it’s important to be kind—to brighten somebody’s day and help somebody smile. “It’s the best thing you can do for someone,” she says. Kindness, true kindness, where you compliment somebody because they deserve it or you listen to somebody who needs to be heard, is so raw it makes my heart swell.

But when you’re out of the groove for too long—away from your passions for too long—it feels like you’re missing some part of yourself.

Like when I got too swamped with work to write, spending fourteen hours a day at the library and then passing out the second I lay down at night. My eyes hurt so much from staring at Word documents and online articles that the idea of keeping them open for thirty minutes longer to look at more words was painful. And then one of my professors asked us if we kept journals or diaries, and I was about to say I did when I realized I hadn’t picked mine up since August. So the next morning, November 1st, I brought my journal with me throughout the day and filled up eight pages with things I didn’t know I felt.

And like when I told one of my friends how a drunk man had followed me home the night before, shouting terrifying things about what he saw and what he wanted to see, and she said, “That sucks, I’m sorry.” Then she ducked her head back into her book, and I was alone next to her. But when I told one of my friends from home, she said, “I don’t really know how to help you feel better or what I should say, but I am so sorry, and if you ever want to talk about it I’ll always listen to you.” And I put my head on her shoulder and nearly cried. Her kindness helped make me feel more whole.

And one of the best parts of life is when these moments of wholeness and passion pop up randomly.

Like when I was sitting on a bench on day and a leaf, split red and yellow right down the middle, landed in my lap. I picked it up and studied the light brown veins that kept the leaf together, and wrote a three-page, terrible poem about it. “Bad art,” my friend calls it. “It’s meant to be bad,” she says. And that what makes it beautiful, I always think. That poem is one of my favorite things I’ve written.

And when a friend texted me, “Hey beautiful!!! I wanted to send a quick text to encourage you today to live your best Monday even though Mondays are terrible. I hope that school life will be less stressful for you and that you're able to remember how truly loved you are by all of your close friends. Hoping and praying that you have an uplifting week and a wonderful day.” I felt a surge of love pump through my heart.

When you feel something, a stirring, maybe, in places you didn’t know existed inside you—that’s when you know you’re in love with something. And when you get so mesmerizingly lost in something—that’s when you know you’re passionate about it. I’ve rarely had one without the other.

And that’s what makes One Nation Under a Groove so interesting and confusing to me, because it stirs things inside me and I can feel it course through my bloodstream, and I just appreciate it. I don’t love it. I’m not passionate about it. It’s not writing or kindness or the people I love. It’s not a music that I can’t live without.

It’s just really, really good.

—Nicole Efford

#178: Curtis Mayfield & the Impressions, "The Anthology: 1961-1977" (1992)

Disclaimer: This is one of those questionable picks that pepper the list: 16 years of music in a greatest hits double album…. Not sure that’s a particularly fair means of assessment or an accurate picture of Curtis Mayfield as an artist. For the sake of fairness I’d be happy to go straight to the late-‘60s and early ‘70s political flowering and Blaxploitation soundtrack cuts and skip the Motown-esque love songs of the Impressions years, as fine as they are. If, however, Rolling Stone had made the sensible rule against including greatest hits albums (which they really should have done), I’ll happily take Curtis, Roots, or the Superfly soundtrack and put it up against any other album in this general numerical range on the RS list (Curtis, his 1970 solo debut must have been a mammoth shock to the system: the opening cut, “If There’s a Hell Below, We’re All Going to Go…” Holy gawd! Get a load of me! A list of society’s ills followed by the lyric, “Nixon talking about, Don’t Worry.” America is great already.) Now I discover Superfly is already on the RS list at no. 72, one hundred-plus long albums away, despite several of its songs appearing on this anthology. I don’t get it. Anyway, sailing on. End Disclaimer.

In eighth grade, I bought a cassette tape from the bargain rack at Kemp Mill Music (same place I bought Hysteria, my contribution at #464, full price though) with a cool Black Caesar, Fred Williamson-looking dude in a colorful suit holding a gun in one hand and a scantily dressed babe in the other on the cover. It was entitled Greatest Pimpin’ Hits or something similar and anthologized many of the classic soundtrack cuts of ‘70s Blaxploitation-era cinema. Isaac Hayes’s “Shaft,” of course; Bobby Womack’s “Across 110th Street” and Marvin Gaye’s “Troubleman” are other ones I remember, along with Curtis Mayfield’s “Superfly.” Come to think “Pusherman” and “Freddie’s Dead” were on the tape as well. I would imagine three tunes making Curtis the leading representative of Greatest Pimpin’ Hits. If the pimp shoe fits.

I loved this cassette tape. Listened to it all the time. Not because Inestled in an affluent Washington, D.C. suburbwas particularly aware of the socioeconomic context and political backdrop of these films, or had ever even seen any of them at the time, but because it was damn funky soul music. I remember one summer I was mowing lawnsI hated mowing lawnsdespised it with all my heartand it was a regular in my Walkman. Now for a related embarrassing suburban-white-kid-early-‘90s-cluelessness anecdote: as junior high schoolers it was required of me and my buddies to hang out at the local mall, where we occasionally partook in the activity of “Pimpin’.” This meant we would dress up in ‘70s clothes gathered from the basement, attic, or bargain bin and strut around the mall blaring Greatest Pimpin’ Hits from a boombox. Curtis Mayfield’s smooth falsetto: “I’m your momma, I’m your daddy, I’m that nigger in the alley / I’m your doctor, when in need, want some coke, have some weed” and our long strides around the Sbarro’s and Cinnabon. Nigh 25 years ago in suburban Virginia we thought that was pretty sweet. Nowadays maybe not so much. I recall the people from the Glamour Shots appreciated it anyway, gifting us with some fine 8 x 10 glossies in our pimp gear in exchange for momentarily enlivening the tedious hours of their mall working day. Ah, the foibles of youth.

Having thankfully moved on from my pimping years, I came back to Curtis Mayfield via my preferred genre of metal, courtesy Fishbone’s cover of “Freddie’s Dead.” Thrashing about in the pit at some humid summer festival: hey, I know this songwait a second, this is from that tape! Then picking up this very anthology I earlier denigrated Rolling Stone for selecting at a used record store in a strip mall in Vienna, VA.

If I had to name my all-time favorite band, Bad Brains would get a better than decent shot at the title (as they will never ever see a list like this, I will include them here). Along with being righteous heavy music, Bad Brains tick all my personal boxes: subvert expectations, crash genre, local boys to boot, but as I think about it, maybe there is also some related connection to my early courtship with Curtis. They are, foremost, city music: Curtis from Chicago; Bad Brains, my own D.C. and later NYC when they were forced to relocate in search of an audience and clubs where they were allowed to play (see: “Banned in DC”). Their music speaks to an awareness and connection with legitimate social concerns developed from real experience and expressed in a kick-ass musical fashion. (The Clash is another band that does this for me—not coincidentally sharing the roots-reggae gene with Bad Brains.) Pusherman and Troubleman and Freddie-on-the-corner are from the same place that led to Bad Brains’ HR (Human Rights) screaming in “Big Takeover,” “Understand me when I say / There's no love for this USA / This world is doomed with its own segregation / Just another Nazi test.” And back to Curtis with another sentiment that hasn’t changed much these many decades later: “We’re all built up with progress / But sometimes I must confess / We deal with rockets and dreams / But reality what does it mean / Ain’t nothin’ said / ‘Cause Freddie’s dead.”

—Erik Wennermark